Carmichael Show Premiere Tackles Rape, Consent and President Trump

When The Carmichael Show last aired over a year ago, Jerrod and his family were split among presidential candidates Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump. In Wednesday’s Season 3 premiere, Trump, now president, is once again at the center of a discussion — this time about rape culture and the importance of consent.

In “Yes Means Yes,” Maxine learns that her former co-worker Sarah has written a Facebook post in which she reveals she was raped. Maxine reads the post at the dinner table; to sum up, Sarah writes that she went back to a man’s place and agreed to make out with him but never agreed to have sex. Afterward, Joe, Cynthia and Jerrod express doubt as to whether she was actually raped. Jerrod even goes so far as to say that “if we just jump to conclusions, a rape accusation can really ruin a man’s life.” Disgusted by the response, Maxine argues that verbal consent is always required, which leads to a larger discussion about rape fantasies and safe words — you know, like Nekeisha’s safe word: Mike Pence.

Bobby, attempting to absorb all of this information, suddenly stands at the far end of the table, petrified that he might have raped a one-night stand during a drunken hook-up. As he explains to the family, the sexual encounter seemed innocent enough, but he was too intoxicated to remember whether he was ever given a verbal “yes.” He doesn’t remember her ever saying “no,” either… except for before their date, when she playfully told him that they definitely weren’t having sex that night.

The Carmichaels’ conversation then transitions back to Jerrod’s earlier point. Being the contrarian that he is, Jerrod argues that being falsely accused of rape can be nearly as damaging on the psyche as the act of rape itself. Maxine quickly dismisses the idea, pointing out that those famously accused, but never convicted — such as Kobe Bryant, Roman Polanski, Julian Assange and Cee Lo Green — all have continued to find work. She then suggests that the election of President Trump — without ever mentioning him by name — is proof that the country as a whole doesn’t pay enough attention to sexual assault or its victims.

“A man that bragged about sexually assaulting women, and then dismissed it as ‘locker room talk,’ was elected president of the United States,” she says, alluding to Trump’s infamous Access Hollywood bus tape scandal. “Clearly, we don’t take it seriously enough.”

Bobby, whose fear isn’t helped by the fact that his date hasn’t responded to any of his texts, is further terrified when she posts the following tweet: “Trying to forget about last night, but I can’t. Need good energy right now.” And that’s when he decides to confront her in person, because “the only thing worse than being the type of guy that does something like this is being the kind of guy who tries to get away with it.”

The woman, whose name we learn is Natalie, ultimately assures Bobby that she wanted to have sex with him and that he did nothing wrong. As for her earlier tweet? Well, Bobby just happens to be really bad at sex, and she’d like to forget about their encounter altogether. (Needless to say, there won’t be a second date.)

What did you think of The Carmichael Show‘s discussion on rape culture, and the Season 3 premiere as a whole?

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

14 Comments
  1. jason says:

    it was pretty good. they’re handling issues with pretty good insight and humor.

  2. Luis Roman says:

    I love this show SO much!!!

  3. Laurel Lane says:

    I was very disappointed in the show tonight and I had looked forward to its return. I don’t think rape should ever be a subject used for laughs. I also didn’t feel it was a very balanced approach to the subject, which normally the show is pretty good at doing. Some of the lines were not all funny tho they were meant to be. If this had been the first time I’d ever seen this show, it would have been my last.

    • Chris says:

      The point of comedy is to make people laugh at things there not comfortable with. I thought they did a great job as this show has since day one of treading the line between funny and insensitive. Glad it’s back on I missed this show!

      • Laurel Lane says:

        Maybe you should talk to a rape survivor and see if they found any humor in it. I’m sorry but I found it in very poor taste.

    • Liz Lemon says:

      That was a brilliant episode. It was not making fun of rape, it was using comedy to shine a light on it.

  4. Morris says:

    The show still brings the laughs and discusses issues like the first two seasons

  5. Felicia inniss says:

    I thought the show was distastfull rape is not a joke . The writers should be ashamed to make a joke about such a serious subject.

    • TV Gord says:

      They did not do that. They dealt with it in an intelligent manner that used humor very effectively. It wasn’t disrespectful.

  6. I love comedies that can find humor in a dark place and this show does it well. So glad that it’s back.

  7. E. D. Boddy says:

    If Trump is going to be referenced, it should be noted he has never been accused of rape. Bill Clinton, on the other hand, HAS been accused of rape, but Hillary threatened the accuser, and nearly everyone else either ignored it or laughed it off. Miss Two-Face later said accusers should be believed. Sure, Hillary.

    • BM says:

      Trump has never been accused of rape? That’s cute. There are multiple accusations (one by one of his ex-wives even, the other from a 13-year-old) plus accusations of sexual assault.

  8. serj tankian says:

    the rape charges against Julian Assange is already dropped. for an uptodate show like carmichael show to not reflect this is sloppy. unless they wanna show that she doesn’t know what she is talking about.

  9. Faith Boyce says:

    On the Carmichael “Sexual Consent” show. Maxine referred to what Trump SAID on a bus decades ago about groping women. I would remind you President Clinton did more than grope IN the Oval Office and President Kennedy had many “sleep-overs” with secret service help maintaining privacy. Whether or not the above occurred with consent, it was NOT appropriate presidential behavior.