Sweet Magnolias has done it again, leaving fans hanging precariously from a number of cliffs as its dramatic second season draws to a close — a situation made all the more stressful by the fact that Netflix has yet to renew the show for Season 3. (UPDATE: The show is now officially renewed.)
And while showrunner Sheryl J. Anderson isn’t ready to spill all of Serenity’s secrets quite yet, she did her best to answer all of TVLine’s burning questions about that twist-filled finale. From the mysterious lunatic who slashed Dana Sue’s tires to the million-dollar question Ryan proposed to Helen, we have no shortage of twists to ponder. And we haven’t even mentioned the skeletons that came spilling out of Cal’s closet, including the potential arrival of a ghost from his past.
We also picked JoAnna Garcia, Heather Headley and Brooke Elliott’s brains for their reactions to their characters’ biggest surprises in that game-changing finale. (In case you missed it, click here for the group’s reactions to the reveal of Isaac’s birth, easily the biggest “WTF” moment of Season 2.)
Grade the finale and the season in our polls below, then read on for Anderson and the cast’s thoughts on all things Serenity. When you’re done, drop a comment with the cliffhanger(s) that are already driving you crazy.