Danielle Brooks OITNB Season 5

Performer of the Week: Danielle Brooks

THE PERFORMER | Danielle Brooks

THE SHOW | Orange Is the New Black

THE EPISODE | “Sing It, White Effie”

THE PERFORMANCE | The 2017 Emmy Awards are still months away, but after seeing Brooks’ triumphant work in the prison dramedy’s fifth season, we’re already thinking ahead to the 2018 Emmy cycle. Anyone who’s watched Episode 5 is likely doing the same.

When Taystee emerged from Litchfield’s barricaded entrance, the press was at first less concerned with her than the well-being of Martha Stewart stand-in Judy King. But ultimately, it was Poussey’s best friend, a ball of pent-up anger over her murder, who got — and held — the reporters’ attention. With painstaking force, Brooks delivered a speech that started as an attempt to do right by the fallen inmate and, along the way, became a devastating critique of racial and class inequity, and an unjust judicial system.

“Our fight is not with Judy King. Our fight is with a system that don’t give a damn about poor people… and brown people… and poor, brown people. Our fight,” Taystee said, pausing to wipe away tears, “is with the folks who hold our demands in their hands… Those demands are fair and necessary, and show that we intend to keep this demonstration peaceful and focused on change.”

And just like that, not only did Taystee become the unofficial face of the ongoing protest happening at Litchfield, but Brooks became the true star of OITNB‘s fifth season. “You ever think about a career in the church?” Allison asked after Taystee made her way back inside. “That was something.” As for Brooks, she’s something else.

HONORABLE MENTION | She’s been a villain all season long on The Handmaid’s Tale, but Yvonne Strahovski expertly peeled back yet more layers to dutiful wife Serena Joy in this week’s finale, revealing a conflicted heart at her core. Strahovski was terrifying as Serena savagely lashed out at Offred for her secret rendezvous with Commander Fred, and chillingly cruel when Serena teased Offred with a glimpse of her daughter, only to heartlessly yank her away. But Serena also stood up to her husband Fred, confronting him about his lies and hypocrisy. Strahovski’s rubbed-raw intensity as Serena unloaded on Fred — “You can’t father a child because you’re not worthy” — almost made us root for her. Almost.

HONORABLE MENTION | It’s kind of a shame that each season of Fargo is a self-contained story, because that means we won’t get to see much more of Olivia Sandoval‘s terrific work as Minnesota traffic cop Winnie Lopez. The newcomer has been a delight as the plainspoken Winnie, using her Midwestern common sense to help Gloria crack the Emmit Stussy case. And this week’s bar scene was a Winnie highlight, with Sandoval playing Winnie’s fertility overshares for laughs (“Thank God for K-Y”) and also delivering a genuinely touching moment, as Winnie wrapped up Gloria in a warm hug to remind her she does exist, and people aren’t all bad. “I like ya,” Winnie told Gloria. Right back atcha, Ms. Sandoval.

HONORABLE MENTION | The brilliance of Tony Hale‘s work in the “Judge” episode of Veep isn’t so much that he was funny to the nth degree. We would — and he proved us right to — expect that he’d easily wring laughs from birthday boy Gary being unfavorably compared to his stillborn brother and oblivious to his father’s “secret” sexual orientation. What we didn’t anticipate — and perhaps should have from the two-time Emmy winner — was the heartrending pathos that he packed into not only the scene in which Selina betrayed her bag man by co-opting the personal anecdote he’d intended to share with his party guests but the one that followed, in which he used full-on Mama Rose moves to out his dad as “a big, fat, flaming bully.” Painful. Hilarious. Amazing.

Which performance knocked your socks off this week? Tell us in Comments!

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

17 Comments
  1. Spence says:

    Danielle was absolutely incredible!!

    • The Beach says:

      The anger and hurt she showed when she had the gun to Piscatella’s head were palpable. And you could feel her hurt when she realized she had let her own demands for justice for Pousse ruin all the good she had done for the other prisoners up until then. Great job.

    • Matt says:

      Was that the same episode? Because if so….then it’s inhumane for her to not get an award for there episode…it was packed…

  2. Candace says:

    Danielle Brooks deserves all the awards.

  3. KC says:

    Taystee was awesome this season.

  4. T. says:

    She definitely is the heart of the show

  5. GregJ. says:

    Love her. Come award season she needs to rack up. Tony Hale great episode. I love President Meyer, but I was upset with her for stealing his story.

  6. Joey Padron says:

    Yvonne did great on Handmaid’s Tale.

  7. dude says:

    Ever since season 2, Danielle Brooks has quietly become OITNB’s true female lead. I really hope she’s recognized come awards season.

  8. Cate says:

    Great picks this week. Danielle Brooks has been the MVP of OITNB for a while, but largely for comedic reasons. She was brilliant as spokesperson Taystee in that episode.

    Yvonne Strahovski has been fantastic as so vile but oddly sympathetic Serena. I want to hate her and she certainly deserved June’s angry abuse this week, but she is someone trapped in the system too. The fact she helped bring it about just makes her all the more pitiful. Strahovski makes Serena fascinating and awful at the same time

  9. Grace says:

    Danielle killed it!

    Yvonne didn’t make me root for it made me want to slap her but that being said she did kill it this week!

    Good choices all around!

  10. Jec says:

    Great choices! Each one richly deserved

  11. dan says:

    Watched episode 5 of OITNB today: your choice of Danielle Brooks as POW was spot on! She was terrific! Brought tears to my eyes in a natural way (not manipulated with background music or mood lighting or fancy camera angles). Still not sure if I like the way this season of OITNB is being presented, but some of the performances have been terrific with Danielle being the standout thus far.

  12. Jermey says:

    Danielle is the star of Seasons 4 and 5.

  13. H Juneau says:

    I’ve never used the expression “jump the shark” to express my opinion of a tv show. I just finished watching this season and not since the actual jumping of the shark has a show deserved to be described that way.
    Ad good as this show has been, this season is just awful.

  14. JD says:

    I don’t know what you folks are watching… Brooks isn’t even the best actor on OITNB. And Fargo has at least 3 actors turning in more nuanced performances than Brooks. She delivers dialogue like a dinner theater performer doing “Fences” in Peoria.

    Of course, Emmy nominations don’t necessarily honor the best acting, so I wouldn’t be surprised to see Brooks’ singled out… doesn’t make her performance any less hammy.