Legion Review: An Exhilarating Delight, Even if You Don't Like Comic Books

grade_AI know what you’re thinking: Another comic-book show? From The CW’s crowded superhero stable to Netflix’s Daredevil/Jessica Jones/Luke Cage trio, it seems like every other TV drama these days springs from the panels of a comic book. And yet, thankfully, there’s still room for a fresh voice in there, because FX’s Legion is not just “another comic-book show.” Visually inventive and emotionally astute, it bursts out of the gate with the most exhilarating TV pilot I’ve seen since Mr. Robot.

The bulk of the credit for Legion — debuting Wednesday, Feb. 8 at 10/9c — goes to creator Noah Hawley, who proved he can revitalize a franchise with FX’s Fargo. As he did there, Hawley uses the original Legion comic books not as a strict blueprint, but as a jumping-off point to create his own universe — one splashed with light, sound and color. Legion not only doesn’t look like any other superhero show; it doesn’t look like anything else on TV. And that’s a good thing.

The story centers on David Haller (Downton Abbey‘s Dan Stevens), a troubled young man trapped in a bleak mental institution. We learn through flashbacks that he had a rough upbringing spiked with violent outbursts, and has now been placed on a numbing pill regimen. But the arrival of a new patient named Syd (Fargo‘s Rachel Keller) awakens something in him, and he starts to realize that all of his psychological problems might just be his extraordinary abilities fighting to get out.

Legion FX Series Premiere Rachel Keller SydAs we learn, David is a mutant with massive telepathic and telekinetic powers; one observer calls him “the most powerful mutant we’ve ever encountered.” (In the original Marvel comics, David is the son of Professor X, of X-Men fame.) The government fears the damage that his powers could inflict, and looks to “kill him now, before he knows what he is.” But David manages to connect with a team of allies who can help him unlock his potential.

There’s some incredible CGI on display here, including a stunningly elaborate battle scene at the very end of the pilot. But most of Legion‘s eye-candy comes from the gorgeous cinematography and set design, filmed by Hawley with a precision reminiscent of Kubrick and Wes Anderson. Legion‘s pilot is bathed in bold primary colors and filled with inspired song choices like the Rolling Stones’ “She’s a Rainbow” and the Who’s “Happy Jack.” It may be too stylized for some, but for those on its particular wavelength (like me), it’s an absolute tour de force.

legion-best-new-winter-showsDavid and Syd’s romance is essential to the story; it gives us something tangible to lean on amid all the mutant weirdness. Their unique courtship, with her not wanting to be touched and him respectfully keeping his distance, is oddly charming. (She agrees to hold a piece of fabric he’s holding so they can “hold hands.”) And Stevens’ performance helps give the show some emotional heft, as David battles with his inner demons. The supporting cast is loaded, too: Aubrey Plaza is wonderfully mischievous as David’s nutso pal Lenny, and Mackenzie Grey is an instant-classic villain as “The Eye,” a silent henchman with a glass eye and a Phil Spector perm who ominously whittles in the background.

Admittedly, Legion‘s plot gets a bit confusing at times, with “memory glitches,” body switches and random time jumps. But it helps that David is just as confused as we are; he acts as our surrogate, and we figure out how this strange new world works along with him. And after the relentless flash and pizzazz of the pilot, Episode 2 gives us a much-needed chance to catch our breath and learn more about David’s backstory, so we can prepare for the wonders that lie ahead.

Comic-book fans might be eager for Legion to hurry up and get to “the good stuff,” connecting David to the X-Men universe they know and love. But I’m not in any hurry. Speaking as someone with next-to-zero knowledge of comic books, this is the first superhero show I’ll be adding to my DVR’s season-pass list. Legion has created a compelling world that firmly stands on its own… and I look forward to Hawley and the cast dazzling me even more in the weeks to come.

THE TVLINE BOTTOM LINE: With breathtaking visual flair and a charming central romance, Legion quickly races to the top of TV’s comic-book class.

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Mitsotakis says:

    I’ll give it a shot. Of course Netflix can’t be added to one’s DVR, so there is that. Hopefully it’s as close as those 3 comic-book inspired shows are.

  2. Johnny Karate says:

    Is this an “exhilarating delight” the same way that Fargo is a “good show”? If so, I may skip it. If ANYONE else had been behind this show, I would’ve been beyond excited for it.

    • Mitsotakis says:

      First season of Fargo was one of the best seasons ever on TV. Second was very good. So I don’t know about just “a good” show.

  3. Ian says:

    Haven’t watched Fargo, and I’m indifferent on the the cast for this, but I ended up agreeing on TvLine’s review of The Young Pope (an hour I’ll never get back), so I’ll give this a shot.

  4. Joey Padron says:

    Good review of the show’s pilot episode. Excited to check out the show next month!

  5. Danny123 says:

    Hope its more superhero and comic books. Less Fargo. I didn’t like that show. X-men are my favorite marvel heroes so I hope its good.

  6. Dispite the ever increasing Cape TV series out there, i’ll give it a shot. It’s a pity, they didnt schedule this after the seasons ends of supergirl, shield, arrow, flash and legends.

  7. mrmcgee says:

    I’m really eager to see this. I’ve always been fascinated with Legion since he popped up in the New Mutants comic book many many years ago. He was so wonderful and weird and oh so powerful. As much as I have wanted to get into the Netflix shows I haven’t had time and now I feel so behind with them I’m going to make time for this.

  8. Legion never had “original LEGION comic books”. He has always appeared in other books, such as NEW MUTANTS and various X-Men related comics. Also, long time fans who know how David’s powers work will instantly understand everything going on, from Syd’s touch issues and the team trying to help David figure out his powers.

  9. Ben says:

    I have seen more enjoyable dog turds steaming in the park. After watching 5 episodes the only similar experience i can compare this show to is going to the dentist for root canal work. Each time I watched an episode, I was hoping for it to sort itself out yet it only gets worse and more rediculous. waste of time from and idiot trying way to hard to be something different.