Exclusive
Baby Daddy Season 5 Spoilers

Baby Daddy Season 5: The Lying Game's Allie Gonino to Recur as Ben's [Spoiler]

Now that Baby Daddy‘s big love triangle has reached its end, it’s time for Ben to set his sights on someone new — and it sounds like he’s already found her.

Allie Gonino, best known to ABC Family junkies as The Lying Game‘s Laurel Mercer, will recur in the comedy’s upcoming fifth season, TVLine has learned exclusively. She’ll play Sam, a girl who applies for the manager position at Ben and Danny’s bar — and did I happen to mention she was Ben’s high school crush?

Unfortunately, not everyone on the show has fond memories of Sam. She wasn’t exactly the nicest person to Riley in high school, and it’s safe to say their relationship hasn’t improved over time.

Gonino’s post-Lying Game credits include a series regular role on SundanceTV’s The Red Road, as well as a guest spot on CBS’ Hawaii Five-0.

Baby Daddy fans, do you sense a love connection brewing? Drop a comment with your thoughts on Ben’s (potential) new lady below.