Baby Daddy's David DeLuise Previews Riley's Paternity Bombshell, Reveals Multiple Endings

Baby DaddyBen will no longer be the only Baby Daddy on the block after tonight’s episode (ABC Family, 8:30/7:30c), which reveals Riley’s biological father. But if you’re hoping for an early answer to the paternity test, guest-star David DeLuise says, regrettably, you’re out of luck.

RELATED | ABC Family Renews Comedies, Orders Pilots About Addiction, Tennis

“We actually shot both endings,” DeLuise, who plays one of Riley’s possible fathers, tells TVLine. “I’m honestly not aware. I think everybody’s going to find out when the show airs.”

Coincidentally, DeLuise’s character is also named David, and he says that’s not the only similarity they share.

“There’s a lot of me in the character,” the former Wizards of Waverly Place star admits. “I’m very jovial, I love food. [David] is very high-energy, and he runs a bakery.”

Baby DaddyIn addition to the episode’s big reveal, fans can also expect major friction between David and Riley’s other potential father, played by The Secret Circle‘s Adam Harrington.

“We were rivals in high school, and we’re still rivals to this day,” DeLuise explains. “He’s a very nice guy, but he’s a lawyer, so he’s a little starch. I’d say I’m Play-Doh and he’s starch.”

Regardless of the outcome, DeLuise is keeping his fingers crossed for David. After all:

“She’s the most wonderful, funny, talented [girl],” he says of Riley. “Who wouldn’t want to be her dad and have that energy in his life?”

Baby Daddy fans, do you think David is Riley’s secret father? Drop a comment with your thoughts on the baby bombshell below.