Fall TV Report Card: Did Your Freshman Faves Make the Grade? Did 'Doomed' Noobs Get Axed?

Beginning with Premiere Week back in September and throughout the fall TV season, TVLine asked you to weigh in and assign a grade to each of the new pilots — from Sleepy Hollow, which was first out of the gate, to Almost Human. When all was said and done and the numbers came in, did you prove to be prescient with your predictions, or wildly off the mark?

RELATED | 2014 Renewal Scorecard: What’s Coming Back? What’s Cancelled? What’s on the Bubble?

As we slog through this holiday break, TVLine tallied up the average grade you assigned each freshman series as well as excerpted reader comments both in the vein of “Yea!” and “Nay!” How did your knee-jerk first impressions wind up comparing to each noob’s ultimate fate? Flip through the slideshow below — arranged from lowest grades to highest — and see!