Putting together pre-season rankings on Dancing With the Stars is usually as easy as separating the Michael Boltons from the Nicole Scherezingers. But the show’s upcoming All-Star season presents a far more rigorous challenge: 11 of the 13 celebrities in the cast managed to make the finals their first time around, and six of them marched all the way to Mirrorball glory. In other words, the talent pool is as closely matched as it is deep.
We’ve taken a crack at ranking the Season 15 couples — from least- to most-likely to win — along with their strengths, weaknesses, and odds of winning it all. So click through our predictions below, then hit the comments with your own prognosticating!