The Season 2 finale introduced Paul Rudd as Charles’ new costar Ben Glenroy. On the opening night of their play, TV’s erstwhile Brazzos confronted the renowned theatre actor about his problematic behavior. “Stay away from her,” he cautioned. “I know what you did.”
But who is “her”? And what, exactly, did Ben do?
Only Murders showrunner John Hoffman previously told TVLine that Rudd will return and continue to give “a touch of a–hole” in Season 3. In the interim, we’re determined to figure out who this mysterious “her” may be. Scroll down to review the seven most likely candidates, then wager a guess in Comments.