Law & Order Took on the Gun Control Debate in Season 22 Finale — Grade It
The gun control debate took center stage in Law & Order’s Season 22 finale, which aired on Thursday night.
Tensions were high after a U.S. senator was shot and killed at his daughter’s wedding. After reviewing footage from the incident, Shaw and Cosgrove realized their suspect was a waiter whose face was obscured by a KN95 mask. (He might have been a murderer, but at least he was being COVID-conscious.)
The detectives eventually found their guy, Derek Quinn, who was distraught and ready to end his life over the rampant gun violence in the country. He was upset with the senator for changing his vote on a gun law. Shaw talked Derek down, and officers took him into custody.
During a press conference, Jack McCoy revealed that this case would be prosecuted in state court.
“Gun violence is a national plague. The only way to affect real change is to move past all the political acrimony and pass strong and effective common sense gun control legislation,” he told reporters. “The question for all of us is, ‘Had enough?’ We can’t become a place where people settle their political differences at the point of gun, or where talented and passionate men and women avoid public service out of fear for their lives.”
The case was an unusually complicated one for McCoy since his daughter Rebecca (played by Sam Waterston’s real-life daughter, Elisabeth Waterston) was representing the defendant. He put on a brave face when Price asked how they should proceed. “I love my daughter dearly,” McCoy said, “but this is just another case, and she is just another lawyer.”
At the arraignment, Derek pleaded not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, saying that he suffered from PTSD after surviving one of the deadliest school shootings in America. (Derek disarmed that shooter and saved lives, but hadn’t been the same since.)
Price, McCoy and Maroun debated the ethics of the case, with McCoy pointing out that regardless of Derek’s previous heroics, he shouldn’t get a free pass for killing a senator out of revenge. Price agreed, legally, but pointed out that morally, some might see it differently, which could lead to jury nullification. Given that the attack was premeditated, McCoy refused to budge on the first-degree murder charge.
During the trial, Price suffered a mild panic attack while holding the gun used to kill the senator, and requested a recess. He tried to brush it off, but Maroun reminded him that he went through a similar experience and he was suffering from PTSD. (Note: Price survived a subway shooting earlier in the season.)
Price was moved by a psychiatrist’s testimony on PTSD and urged McCoy to offer a plea deal, but the best they could offer was first-degree manslaughter, which came with a 15-year sentence. Rebecca rejected the deal, and Derek was subsequently found guilty of first-degree murder.
Nobody was happy about the verdict, including McCoy, who looked solemn in the back of the courtroom. Rebecca, angry with her father for his lack of empathy during the case, turned down his offer to dinner.
Price was right when he said that McCoy was trying too hard to not look like he was favoring his daughter. It may have just cost him a relationship with her.
What did you think of the Law & Order finale? Grade the episode below and then share your thoughts in the comments.
Shame on Rebecca for trying to use the fact that Jack is her dad to do things her way and then to say no to dinner because she didn’t get her way? She should’ve known better than anyone it is wrong to consult with the D.A. like that.
I’m sympathetic to and would love to see gun reform. But the perpetrator in this case blatantly went to the victim’s wedding and shot him while he was dancing with his daughter. It was hard to elicit sympathy under those circumstances and we’re not going to solve violent problems with more problems.
There is something comforting about Jack McCoy existing in the L&O universe. That is all!!!
Yes!
The thing I don’t get is that the Second Amendment literally says “well-regulated.” Aren’t gun safety laws part of that? So bizarre.
And, of course, it’s referring to a well-regulated militia, which has always made it plausible (at least to me) that the right to gun ownership was intended to serve the states’ rights to maintain their own militias. NOT this unrestrained horror show that people have created through widespread ownership of weapons of war.
In 2018 CNN did a segment about the wording and this is what their reporting came to…
“Well-regulated in the 18th century tended to be something like well-organized, well-armed, well-disciplined. It didn’t mean ‘regulation’ in the sense that we use it now… It means the militia was in an effective shape to fight.”
I liked that the season finale gave so much time to Sam Waterston. (Elisabeth has her father’s eyes – fun to see dad & daughter together.) Liked that the show took on an issue with some teeth. I’m betting that in real life such circumstances at a trial would have ended with a hung jury.
Very good performance of Sam Waterston!!! My guess for The Performer of the week.
This was a very upsetting case! But how it played out was fairly predictable. I knew as soon as she rejected the plea deal that the jury would find him guilty. Prior to that, I had doubt.
In real life, this would have been a Federal Case since the FBI would have taken the lead just like they do on the FBI shows.. But we don’t see Federal trials on FBI so it has to work this way…
Guns took center stage with McCoy when he took on the gun manufacturers-11 years ago.