Glee‘s Mr. Schue Was Written for Justin Timberlake, Says Ryan Murphy — and the Character Was Originally an Addict
Glee nearly brought sexy back with its casting of Mr. Schuester.
Series co-creator Ryan Murphy divulged on Sunday that singer-actor Justin Timberlake was the original choice to play Glee‘s cheery Spanish teacher-turned-glee club director, who was ultimately portrayed by Matthew Morrison.
“When we were writing the pilot — I’ve never really talked about this — that pilot was written for Justin Timberlake. Mr. Schue was written for Justin,” Murphy revealed on the inaugural episode of And That’s What You REALLY Missed, a podcast hosted by Glee co-stars Jenna Ushkowitz and Kevin McHale (aka Tina and Artie).
After noting that the Timberlake tidbit was “brand-new information” to him, McHale ended the episode, with the second half of Murphy’s interview — and more Timberlake intel, presumably — to be saved for Episode 2. But aside from that near-casting bombshell, Murphy also gave fresh insight into how Glee came about, sharing that co-creator Ian Brennan’s original script was “a very dark comedy” in which Mr. Schuester used drugs and had inappropriate relationships with his students.
“Mr. Schue, I believe, was a crystal meth addict in Ian’s script,” Murphy said. “It was sort of like [the 1999 film] Election, but like the NC-17 version of show choir with a weird protagonist who was unraveling.”
At the time that Murphy received Brennan’s script — one of Brennan’s friends handed the pages to Murphy while he was at the gym — he had recently finished working on Nip/Tuck at FX, and the network had just passed on Murphy’s follow-up, Pretty/Handsome, which was to star Joseph Fiennes as a male gynecologist “who realizes he’s a woman,” per Murphy. (The show got no support from advertisers.)
Thus, on the heels of tonally dark subject matter and professional disappointment, Murphy said he was looking for a project that was “pop-y and primary colors and blue sky and not dark.” Brennan agreed to rework his original Glee script to be more optimistic, and the show ultimately moved forward after getting early support from then-Fox exec Dana Walden.
Can you envision a Glee with Timberlake in the lead role? Or an NC-17 version of show choir, for that matter?
I’ve never read something that makes more sense. Of course Justin was supposed to be Mr. Shue. That’s where that cringy swagger vibe came from.
I felt the same way! Suddenly the character makes more sense, actually
Fun Fact: Matthew Morrison was also in a boy band.
LMNT. For a hot minute.
With Ikaika from the OG Making the Band!
Not only can I imagine it, I would have preferred it!! (Not dissing the show, just saying that the constant dialing down & censorship of what I considered to be fairly normal words & deeds was incredibly annoying.) Glee w sex, real high school deeds & language, music without “changes” would have been fantastic!!
I’m so glad they cast Matthew Morrison in that role. He was perfect for it!!
I can honestly see that; he did seem a little Timberlake to me
This feels somewhat revisionist to me in that in the past Ryan has never seemed to given Ian credit for the idea. He always takes credit for the show.
Also this is seriously like Kevin and Jenna’s third attempt at this podcast.
Justin would’ve have done it. He’s such a diva.