Before Eric Dane McSteamed up Grey Sloan Memorial, before Julian McMahon made Miami beautiful, and before Nick Lachey was asked to stay out of Tree Hill, all three men fell under the spell of Charmed‘s Phoebe Halliwell. And they weren’t alone.
In her never-ending quest for love, Alyssa Milano’s character crossed paths (and occasionally swapped wedding vows) with a who’s who of 2000s TV, and each suitor left a profound impact on her heart. In the spirit of celebrating the ones that got away, TVLine is taking a stroll down memory lane to remember which of Phoebe’s relationships (including two demons and a cupid!) we’ll never forget.
(Side note: All eight seasons of Charmed are currently streaming on Peacock in glorious HD — albeit with that questionable new theme song — in case you feel like doing your own deep dive.)
Read on for our ranking of Phoebe’s seven most significant pairings, then drop a comment with your own thoughts on her love life.