Related Galleries
Teen Wolf's Best & Worst 
Riverdale Season 2 Photos 
Supernatural Season 13 Photos
1 of 46
TV's Best, Worst and Most of 2016 (Part 1)
MOST UNDERRATED DRAMA
Halt and Catch FireRUNNER-UP
The Girlfriend Experience
MOST UNDERRATED DRAMA ACTOR
Mark-Paul Gosselaar, PitchRUNNER-UP
Andrew Lincoln, The Walking Dead
MOST UNDERRATED DRAMA ACTRESS
Abigail Spencer, Rectify and TimelessRUNNER-UP
Caterina Scorsone, Grey’s Anatomy
MOST UNDERRATED COMEDY
SuperstoreRUNNER-UP
Documentary Now
MOST UNDERRATED COMEDY ACTOR
Lamorne Morris, New GirlRUNNER-UP
William Jackson Harper, The Good Place
BEST SINGLE EPISODE (DRAMA)
“The Winds of Winter,” Game of ThronesRUNNER-UP
“Marcia, Marcia, Marcia,” The People v. O.J. Simpson
BEST SINGLE EPISODE (COMEDY)
“Mother,” VeepRUNNER-UP
“Fish Out of Water,” BoJack Horseman
BEST GUILTY PLEASURE (DRAMA)
LuciferRUNNER-UP
The Last Ship
BEST GUILTY PLEASURE (COMEDY)
Fuller HouseRUNNER-UP
Impastor
BEST GUILTY PLEASURE (REALITY)
The Great British Baking ShowRUNNER-UP
Bachelor in Paradise
MOST IMPROVED DRAMA
Orange Is the New BlackRUNNER-UP
Supergirl
MOST IMPROVED COMEDY
GirlsRUNNER-UP
New Girl
BIGGEST ACTING REVELATION (DRAMA)
Justin Hartley, This Is UsRUNNER-UP
Ruth Negga, Preacher
BIGGEST ACTING REVELATION (COMEDY)
Rose Abdoo, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the LifeRUNNER-UP
Micah Fowler, Speechless
STEALTHIEST CASTING
Sarah Shahi popping up on PitchMOST DISAPPOINTING SHOW
The CatchRUNNER-UP
Beauty and the Beast‘s final season
BEST SERIES FINALE
Penny DreadfulRUNNER-UP
American Idol
WORST SERIES FINALE
The Good WifeRUNNER-UP
Castle
CANCELLATION THAT HURT THE MOST
Marvel’s Agent CarterRUNNER-UP
Togetherness
MOST AMBITIOUS ILL-FATED SHOW
BrainDeadRUNNER-UP
Undateable Live
BEST NEW SHOW THAT TOO FEW WATCH
Better ThingsBEST MONOLOGUE
Lorelai on the phone with her mom, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the LifeRUNNER-UP
Laurie Metcalf, Horace and Pete
BEST EXTENDED SCENE SANS DIALOGUE
Daniel reunites (?) with Chloe, and her baby, RectifyRUNNER-UP
Casual‘s Leon finds (and loses) a girlfriend
BEST COSTUMES
OutlanderRUNNER-UP
Westworld
BEST CAMEO
Joshua Jackson on Unbreakable Kimmy SchmidtRUNNER-UP
Michael Ausiello, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life
BEST COMEDY DUO
Tituss and Lillian, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt
RUNNER-UP
Eleanor and Chidi, The Good Place
MOST CONVOLUTED STORY ARC
Castle’s “missing” time ties into Beckett’s search for LokSat, CastleRUNNER-UP
Grey’s Anatomy‘s Meredith/ Nathan/ Maggie triangle mishegas
BEST NEW CHARACTER ON AN ESTABLISHED DRAMA
Supergirl‘s Mon-ElRUNNER-UP
Lucifer‘s Charlotte
BEST NEW CHARACTER ON AN ESTABLISHED COMEDY
New Girl‘s ReaganRUNNER-UP
Johan, black-ish
WORST NEW CHARACTER ON AN ESTABLISHED SHOW
The Walking Dead‘s NeganRUNNER-UP
Arrow‘s Rene aka Wild Dog
BEST OPENING CREDITS
Stranger ThingsRUNNER-UP
Westworld
BEST ENSEMBLE
The People v. O.J. SimpsonRUNNER-UP
This Is Us
BEST CLIFFHANGER
Daya grabs the guard’s gun on Orange Is the New BlackRUNNER-UP
“Who did Negan kill?,” The Walking Dead
BEST DEATH SCENE
Norma, Bates MotelWORST DEATH SCENE
Abbie, Sleepy HollowBIGGEST TEARJERKER
Dr. K’s talk with Jack in the This Is Us premiereRUNNER-UP
Claire’s stillbirth, Outlander
THE WIRE MEMORIAL AWARD FOR WORLD-CLASS DRAMA IGNORED IN PERPETUITY BY THE EMMYS
Penny DreadfulACTRESS MOST IN NEED OF A GOOD SHOW
Laura BenantiACTOR MOST IN NEED OF A GOOD SHOW
Dave AnnableBEST REALITY SHOW JUDGE
Miley Cyrus, The VoiceWORST REALITY SHOW JUDGE
Maddie Ziegler, So You Think You Can Dance: The Next GenerationBEST PERFORMANCE IN A REALITY-TV COMPETITION
Alyssa and Tatiana lip sync on Drag Race All Stars 2BEST CGI
Battle of the Bastards, Game of ThronesWORST CGI MOMENT
Jamie standing on the airborne jet’s open cargo ramp, ZooBEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ANIMAL
The cat, The Night OfRUNNER-UP
Tad Cooper, Galavant
Image: Courtesy of ABC
