TV's Best, Worst And Most Of 2016 (Part 1)

MOST UNDERRATED DRAMA

Halt and Catch FireRUNNER-UP The Girlfriend Experience

MOST UNDERRATED DRAMA ACTOR

Mark-Paul Gosselaar, PitchRUNNER-UP Andrew Lincoln, The Walking Dead

MOST UNDERRATED DRAMA ACTRESS

Abigail Spencer, Rectify and TimelessRUNNER-UP Caterina Scorsone, Grey's Anatomy

MOST UNDERRATED COMEDY

SuperstoreRUNNER-UP Documentary Now

MOST UNDERRATED COMEDY ACTOR

Lamorne Morris, New GirlRUNNER-UP William Jackson Harper, The Good Place

BEST SINGLE EPISODE (DRAMA)

"The Winds of Winter," Game of ThronesRUNNER-UP "Marcia, Marcia, Marcia," The People v. O.J. Simpson

BEST SINGLE EPISODE (COMEDY)

"Mother," VeepRUNNER-UP "Fish Out of Water," BoJack Horseman

BEST GUILTY PLEASURE (DRAMA)

LuciferRUNNER-UP The Last Ship

BEST GUILTY PLEASURE (COMEDY)

Fuller HouseRUNNER-UP Impastor

BEST GUILTY PLEASURE (REALITY)

The Great British Baking ShowRUNNER-UP Bachelor in Paradise

MOST IMPROVED DRAMA

Orange Is the New BlackRUNNER-UP Supergirl

MOST IMPROVED COMEDY

GirlsRUNNER-UP New Girl

BIGGEST ACTING REVELATION (DRAMA)

Justin Hartley, This Is UsRUNNER-UP Ruth Negga, Preacher

BIGGEST ACTING REVELATION (COMEDY)

Rose Abdoo, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the LifeRUNNER-UP Micah Fowler, Speechless

STEALTHIEST CASTING

Sarah Shahi popping up on Pitch

MOST DISAPPOINTING SHOW

The CatchRUNNER-UP Beauty and the Beast's final season

BEST SERIES FINALE

Penny DreadfulRUNNER-UP American Idol

WORST SERIES FINALE

The Good WifeRUNNER-UP Castle

CANCELLATION THAT HURT THE MOST

Marvel's Agent CarterRUNNER-UP Togetherness

MOST AMBITIOUS ILL-FATED SHOW

BrainDeadRUNNER-UP Undateable Live

BEST NEW SHOW THAT TOO FEW WATCH

Better Things

BEST MONOLOGUE

Lorelai on the phone with her mom, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the LifeRUNNER-UP Laurie Metcalf, Horace and Pete

BEST EXTENDED SCENE SANS DIALOGUE

Daniel reunites (?) with Chloe, and her baby, RectifyRUNNER-UPCasual's Leon finds (and loses) a girlfriend

BEST COSTUMES

OutlanderRUNNER-UPWestworld

BEST CAMEO

Joshua Jackson on Unbreakable Kimmy SchmidtRUNNER-UPMichael Ausiello, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life

BEST COMEDY DUO

Tituss and Lillian, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

RUNNER-UP
Eleanor and Chidi, The Good Place

MOST CONVOLUTED STORY ARC

Castle's "missing" time ties into Beckett's search for LokSat, CastleRUNNER-UPGrey's Anatomy's Meredith/ Nathan/ Maggie triangle mishegas

BEST NEW CHARACTER ON AN ESTABLISHED DRAMA

Supergirl's Mon-ElRUNNER-UPLucifer's Charlotte

BEST NEW CHARACTER ON AN ESTABLISHED COMEDY

New Girl's ReaganRUNNER-UPJohan, black-ish

WORST NEW CHARACTER ON AN ESTABLISHED SHOW

The Walking Dead's NeganRUNNER-UPArrow's Rene aka Wild Dog

BEST OPENING CREDITS

Stranger ThingsRUNNER-UPWestworld

BEST ENSEMBLE

The People v. O.J. SimpsonRUNNER-UPThis Is Us

BEST CLIFFHANGER

Daya grabs the guard's gun on Orange Is the New BlackRUNNER-UP"Who did Negan kill?," The Walking Dead

BEST DEATH SCENE

Norma, Bates Motel

WORST DEATH SCENE

Abbie, Sleepy Hollow

BIGGEST TEARJERKER

Dr. K's talk with Jack in the This Is Us premiereRUNNER-UPClaire's stillbirth, Outlander

THE WIRE MEMORIAL AWARD FOR WORLD-CLASS DRAMA IGNORED IN PERPETUITY BY THE EMMYS

Penny Dreadful

ACTRESS MOST IN NEED OF A GOOD SHOW

Laura Benanti

ACTOR MOST IN NEED OF A GOOD SHOW

Dave Annable

BEST REALITY SHOW JUDGE

Miley Cyrus, The Voice

WORST REALITY SHOW JUDGE

Maddie Ziegler, So You Think You Can Dance: The Next Generation

BEST PERFORMANCE IN A REALITY-TV COMPETITION

Alyssa and Tatiana lip sync on Drag Race All Stars 2

BEST CGI

Battle of the Bastards, Game of Thrones

WORST CGI MOMENT

Jamie standing on the airborne jet's open cargo ramp, Zoo

BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ANIMAL

The cat, The Night OfRUNNER-UPTad Cooper, Galavant