How I Met Your Mother welcomes back Jayma Mays’ coat check girl on tonight’s episode (CBS, 8/7c), so we have to ask: Is she the mom?
Unfortunately, Ted already ruled out the pixie as his future wife via voiceover in Season 1. But her surprise return got us thinking about the other women who’ve crossed the bachelor’s path and set off our mother-alarm bells.
With the series finish line in sight, TVLine has gathered the eight best candidates for the role of Mrs. Mosby — both those who failed to get the part and two that could still be The One.
Check out the gallery below, and then hit the comments with your thoughts.