American Idol Top '12' Performance Night: Who Was Your Fave? And How About That DQ?

I sure hope everyone enjoyed “Oldies That Happened to Be Covered in the Year the Season 11 Finalists Were Born” Night on American Idol! Yes indeed, more than half of this week’s selected songs made their way into the world long before the finalists who covered ’em.

But who’s counting? Not Uncle Nigel! Then again, in our executive producer’s defense, …READ MORE