TV Stars' Best Halloween Costumes: Colton Haynes as Miss Piggy, Stranger Candice King, a P.I.Ñ.A.T.A. and More

Halloween Costumes TV Stars

So on-the-(ahem)-nose was Arrow alum Colton Haynes’ Halloween costume, it sparked an online beef with the real Miss Piggy.

Haynes — who last year scarily channeled the sea witch Ursula — this year buried himself beneath prosthetic makeup to again “go big or go home” as another diva, leading to a bit of social media shade-throwing:

Haynes, of course, was far from the only TV star to ham it up on Saturday.

Many other familiar faces — who for a living play “dress up” — dressed up in their own special ways for Halloween weekend partying, including The Vampire Diaries’ Candice King, Arrow‘s Emily Bett Rickards, a trio of Shadowhunters, one agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. and a Legend of Tomorrow, among others.

Flip through our first pass at this year’s Halloween photo gallery (to be updated as more celebs wake up and fire up the Instagram), and tell which costumes impressed you most.