Forget Game of Thrones‘ Hall of Faces. Our gallery of the best moments from Thursday night’s Supernatural is a parade of visages, from a sexed-up Sam to a surprised Sam to a shocked Sam. We also threw in a grotesque Lucifer, for good measure.
“Mamma Mia” — which felt like it should have been the season premiere, yes? — brought us several long-awaited scenes, including Sam’s reunion with his brother and his alive-again mother, who started to make an impression. (Perhaps like mom, we just needed some time to adjust to her resurrection?)
Amidst all the Winchester family time, the brothers made the case for why they’re hunters in such a loving way that even the screencaps of those exchanges are bound to make you a little emotional.
Elsewhere, Rick Springfield made a memorable — and bloody — debut as Lucifer’s new vessel, the grief-stricken rock star Vince Vicente.
Click the gallery above to relive the episode’s highlights, then hit the comments with your favorite scenes.