Seth Meyers to Return to Mindy Project

Seth Meyers The Mindy Project Season 4

Seth Meyers is making a repeat visit to The Mindy Project. But, like in any good fro-yo outing, there’s a twist.

Though the Late Night host appeared as Matt, one of Dr. Lahiri’s suitors in a Season 1 episode of the Fox-to-Hulu comedy — helping Mindy nab a tote bag at a local bookstore, then taking her out for frozen yogurt — he’ll play himself in the upcoming midseason premiere, TVLine has learned exclusively.

Meyers’ appearance is part of “a really funny workplace story” at Shulman and Associates, executive producer Matt Warburton tells TVLine. And the Saturday Night Live alum’s resemblance to that fleeting first season love interest? Purely coincidental.

Below, watch a teaser for the second half of the season, which returns Tuesday, then hit the comments with your thoughts on what’s ahead!