Pretty Little Liars Season 6B: Is Toby Punching Caleb in This New Promo?

Just when we think we have a grasp on what to expect when Pretty Little Liars jumps five years into the future this January, along comes another trailer to remind us how truly unprepared we are.

ABC Family over the weekend released an updated look at Season 6B (returning Jan. 12 at 8/7c) with several must-discuss additions, most of which revolve around Caleb.

For starters: Who is he sleeping with at the 0:13 mark? And why is Toby punching him at 0:17? (If that’s really him.) Do I dare make the leap that a Caleb-Spencer hookup could be in the cards? (Too late, I just did.)

OK, enough questions from me. Hit PLAY on the teaser above, then drop a comment with your thoughts and fears.