The Voice's Season 9 Coaches Want Bette Midler to Do What?!

The Voice‘s four red chairs are an essential part of its DNA — but nine seasons in, you can’t blame the show’s coaches for indulging in a little “What if?” daydreaming.

In the following exclusive video, Blake Shelton, Adam Levine, Pharrell Williams and Gwen Stefani offer their dream picks for a fifth coach — and their answers range from the ridiculous (let’s just say Blake’s candidate isn’t exactly known for her pipes) to the sublime (Adam might be on to something!).

Press PLAY below for a trip down Wild Speculation Lane, then hit the comments and brainstorm your own “5th coach” options!