Don’t tell me American Idol is ending in 2016. I’m not acknowledging this crippling news ’til this afternoon (once I can pull myself out of the fetal position and pull some thoughts together for an opinion piece).

Until then, let’s forge ahead with an all new (and Jason Averett-produced) edition of Reality Check, yes?

This week, my co-host Melinda Doolittle and I ponder the worst Voice elimination in the show’s eight-season history — and wonder if coach Christina Aguilera is partially to blame.

We also tackle the penultimate week of Idol‘s 14th season — and debate who will and should make the Top 2 from the current roster of Jax, Nick Fradiani and Clark Beckham.

Press PLAY above for the full discussion, then hit the comments section with your thoughts!