Reality Check: Is Team Xtina Unbeatable on The Voice? Plus: Slezak and Doolittle Pick Their Idol Final 3s!

Disgusting. Magical. “One of the greatest things I’ve ever seen in my life.”

These are just a few of the superlatives my co-host Melinda Doolittle and I hurl at The Voice‘s incredible Season 8 contestants on this week’s installment of Reality Check.

But are we on #TeamYouth, #TeamExperience or #TeamXtina? You’ll find out as you watch us debate The Voice‘s Top 20 Live Playoffs.

Also on the docket? Melinda’s and my controversial, not-quite-definitive picks for American Idol‘s Season 14 Top 3. Plus, a deep dive into our issues with current front-runner Clark Beckham, and a chat about how Tyanna Jones got her groove back.

Press PLAY above for the full Reality Check experience, then share your Voice faves and your Idol final three picks down in the comments!