Finding Carter Season 2 Teaser: The Hunt for Lori Unearths New Secrets

Finding Carter Season 2

“Where the #$%^& is Carter?” That’s just one of the many questions being asked in this exclusive first look at Finding Carter‘s second season, as the MTV drama picks up immediately following the titular gone-girl’s latest kidnapping.

Of course, Carter’s disappearance isn’t the only mystery being explored this season; a scene in the new teaser finds David telling Elizabeth, “There’s things we need to talk about … things about Lori,” while holding that suspicious picture she once took of him sleeping. And what secret was Elizabeth planning to take to her “grave”?

Fans of Max — whose future with the Wilson family appeared tenuous at the end of Season 1 — will also be happy to see that the golden-haired, crouton-cooking ball of sensitivity is still very much in the picture.

Finding Carter kicks off its second season Tuesday, March 31, at 10/9c.

So hit PLAY on the video below, then start cooking up those theories: What’s David’s big secret? Has Elizabeth been helping him hide it? Is Lori super-crazy, or just regular-crazy? Drop a comment with your thoughts below.

GET MORE: Exclusive, Trailers and Promos, Video