Fall TV Report Card: Are Your Freshman Faves Making the Grade? Have Any 'Doomed' Noobs Dodged the Axe?

Fall TV Winners Losers

Beginning in September and throughout the fall, TVLine asked you to grade each of the new pilots — from Fox’s Utopia, which was first (and worst?) out of the gate, to NBC’s recently unveiled State of Affairs. As the numbers started coming in, did you prove to be prescient with your predictions or wildly off the mark?

Last year, American Horror Story: Coven, The Blacklist, Masters of Sex, Almost Human (R.I.P.) and S.H.I.E.L.D. populated your Top 5, while Super Fun Night, We Are Men and Dads brought up the very rear.

This year, TVLine took the precise hand-count of your votes and — with an assist from Sheldon, Leonard and that Scorpion dude — extrapo-convert-ulated it into a numerical grade, with “100%” repping a perfect score. How did your knee-jerk impressions compare to each noob’s fate? And who topped this freshman class? View the slideshow below, arranged from lowest grade to highest.