As the battle for Supreme-acy raged on American Horror Story: Coven last season, a far fiercer battle was happening behind the scenes.
TVLine has an exclusive video from the Coven DVD box set — officially on shelves Tuesday, in advance of Wednesday’s Freak Show premiere — which illustrates the producers’ ongoing debate throughout the season. As co-executive producer Jessica Sharzer reveals, “Right up until the very last episode, we were arguing over who the next Supreme should be.”
The clip even features an interview with (spoiler alert!) eventual Supreme Sarah Paulson, who recalls the fateful moment Ryan Murphy gave her the good news.
Hit PLAY on the video above, then drop a comment with your thoughts on Coven: Was the right Supreme chosen?