Case Closed for Mystery Girls

Mystery Girls Cancelled

UPDATE: ABC Family now confirms Mystery Girls is one-and-done.

Here’s a new case for Mystery Girls‘ amateur sleuths Charlie and Holly: Who killed their TV show?

Although an ABC Family rep maintains that no official decision has been made, TVLine is hearing that the cable net will not be bringing its Tori Spelling-Jennie Garth buddy comedy back for a second season.

RELATED TVLine’s Cable Renewal Scorecard: What’s Cancelled? What’s Returning? What’s on the Bubble?

The campy series ended its run much the same way it started it — with disappointing ratings. The Aug. 27 finale drew slightly more than 500K viewers and a .024 demo rating.