More than eight months ago, as the TV season was just being unleashed, the TVLine staff threw caution to the wind and ventured forth with our predictions for 27 different shows.
All told, we shared our best educated guesses about Grey’s Anatomy contract renewals, the exit of a major Good Wife character, The X Factor‘s fate, Once Upon a Time possibly getting Wicked, a Sleepy Hollow makeover, S.H.I.E.L.D.‘s super premiere numbers, a less-than-Super spin-off and more.
Where did we outright nail it, and where (and how) did we come up a bit short? (And in what instances were we just plain wrong?) In this gallery, we present our original predictions exactly as they appeared in mid-September 2013, accompanied by each outcome.