Supernatural Hot Shots: Dean Meets His [Spoiler]!

Trust issues will be rearing their head again in the Feb. 3 episode of Supernatural (The CW, 9/8c), and we’ve got a sneak peek at the new gal creating drama for the Winchesters.

As the latest promo reveals, Dean’s one night stand with The Vampire Diaries‘ Sara Canning will have very big consequences — like instant fatherhood big.

But it also means trouble for Sam and Dean’s relationship, which experiences a bit of a role reversal.

Supernatural Boss Talks Bobby’s Death, Dean’s ‘Unhealthy’ State, Two Big Returns and Lots More

In the installment, “Sam finds himself in the same situation that Dean was in with Amy,” Jared Padalecki teased to TVLine. “So where it was Dean trying to do the right thing that a hunter would do, even though Sam insisted that he trusted this girl, now we find Sam in that situation, where Dean’s like, ‘Hey, I trust this person,’ and Sam’s going, ‘Well, you’re not in your right mind.’”

Ruh-roh, is Dean’s spawn demonic? From the pained expression on his face in the last photo below, it looks like we may have another “Heart” situation on our hands.

Check out the gallery below and then hit the comments with your thoughts on this new wrinkle.

GET MORE: First Look, Photo Gallery, Previews