How I Met Your Mother First Look Video: Watch Katie Holmes Channel Her Inner Slutty Pumpkin

Next Monday at 8/7c, Ted finally reconnects with his Slutty Pumpkin, Naomi (played by Katie Holmes), on CBS’ How I Met Your Mother, and TVLine’s got a sneak peek at the not-so-perfect reunion.

Halloween Hot Shots: See Who’s Dressed as What on Secret Circle, HIMYM and 9 Other Shows

It’s been years since Ted first laid eyes on the scantily clad gal at a rooftop Halloween party, and it appears time has not been their friend. While Naomi thinks they fit together like two puzzle pieces, Ted just can’t get in sync with her. Even hand-holding presents a problem!

Check out the awkward twosome in action below! And, as an extra Halloween treat, get a preview of Robin taunting Barney about being part Canadian!