Since it seems like there are currently about 15,749 shows on the air and/or in production, it makes perfect sense that this year, you, our dear TVLine readers, would be feeling thankful for a veritable cornucopia of treats.
And now that Team TVLine has shared its small-screen gratitude, it’s time to highlight the 2017 programs, storylines and actors that you are happiest to have enjoyed/be enjoying. From Once Upon a Time‘s reboot to Orphan Black‘s swan song to Tom Welling’s super comeback, you flooded our inbox with a wide range of deserving suggestions. You also dished out extra helpings of the unexpected, giving thanks for the (syndicated) return of a classic TV series and a Netflix feature that has changed your life.
Flip through the gallery above (or click here for direct access) to see the submissions we’ve highlighted, then hit the comments with your own picks!