The Handmaids Tale Recap Season 1 Episode 5

The Handmaid's Tale Recap: Mayday!

Need to catch up? Check out the previous The Handmaid’s Tale recap here. 

Actual title for this week’s episode of The Handmaid’s Tale: “Faithful.” Alternative title for the hour: “How Offred Got Her Groove Back.”

The Handmaid Formerly Known as June has icky, Serena-sanctioned sex with Nick. Then she witnesses a rebellion of epic proportion (which ends in probable tragedy), and then has hot, unsanctioned sex with Nick.

It’s a full week.

Read on for the highlights of the episode.

STUDY DATES | As Offred sits on the floor of the Commander’s study, sipping some booze and toying with her Scrabble tiles, her voiceover informs us that they’ve played 34 games total. The unease between the two is pretty much gone. They flirt. They banter. He gifts her with a contraband women’s magazine — “Those were destroyed,” she says, shocked — and flouts the rules by saying she’s allowed to read it when she’s with hi. They’re quite comfortable, even cozy with each other.

So when Serena Joy asks Offred to help her with some gardening, the handmaid naturally assumes that Mrs. Waterford knows about something. The closet etching? The Scrabble games? The magazine? “Any way you slice it, I lose a hand,” she voiceovers. But nope, blondie just wants to suggest that Offred secretly bone someone else in case the Commander is shooting little bearded blanks. “I was thinking of Nick,” she whispers. “He’s already agreed.” Offred looks like she just got punched, but she agrees. What other choice does she have?

LESS-THAN-HAPPY RETURNS | A surprise, later, at the supermarket: Ofglen is back! Only now she’s called Ofsteven, and she’s quiet and sad. “I don’t know anything anymore. After what happened, I’m too dangerous to be a part of it,” she says, at Offred’s urging. Part of what, Offred wonders? “Mayday,” Ofglen Ofsteven responds.

But before Offred can learn anymore, NuOfglen pulls her away. When she gets home, it’s time for her big date with Nick. As Serena leads her charge up to the driver’s apartment, Offred voiceovers that she’s done this a million times, yet “How come this time it feels like I’m cheating on Luke?”

The Handmaid's Tale Recap Season 1 Episode 5HAPPIER TIMES | A flashback shows us how June and Luke met — when Moira pulled him into a conversation about June’s Tinder photo — and how their relationship progressed. They’d meet for lunch or coffee and were very much into each other, but he was married. Yet after some intensely sexy conversation (Elisabeth Moss and O-T Fagbenie are FIRE in the scenes), they wind up at a hotel to do what people who’ve engaged in months-long foreplay are gonna do.

“I want you to leave your wife,” she says after another tryst. “OK,” he says, surprising her by admitting that he’s in love with her, so what else is he going to do? She responds in kind. Aww. I mean, what a terrible development for Luke’s first wife, right. But aww anyway.

MONSTER IS AS MONSTER DOES | So Nick and Offred have clothes-on, passionless, silent sex while Serena STANDS IN THE ROOM AND KINDA WATCHES THEM. Ugh. Back at the big house, Mrs. Waterford wonders if Offred feels any different, a question so stupid that Offred can’t help but snap at her in response… then cower in fear at the imminent retribution. But rather than getting violent, the Commander’s wife spouts scripture at her handmaid’s pelvic area, then orders her to go lie down.

At The Ceremony later that evening, Offred starts to freak out when Commander Waterford caresses her thigh in full view of Serena. It’s just luck that Mrs. Waterford isn’t paying much attention to the proceedings — and Offred is IRATE when she knocks on Waterford’s study door, uninvited, that evening.

He doesn’t understand why she’s so angry, but offers her another silly magazine in apology. As they talk, she realizes that he’s just as terrible as she always thought: He thinks it’s better for women not to have the choices they used to, because “Now you have respect. You have protection. You can fulfill your biological destinies in peace.” For a kicker, he adds that there’s no such thing as love, and drops the bomb that Ofglen Ofsteven had her “unnatural urges” removed. Oh, is that what we’re calling the clitoris now?

“We only wanted to make the world better,” he says, as Offred looks like she’s going to puke right there on the floor. “Better never means better for everyone. It always means worse for some.”

With his words ringing in her ears, Offred goes and actually vomits in the kitchen sink… where of course Nick sees all. He apologizes for the forced sex later, with the caveat that he couldn’t say no to Serena Joy. Crying, Offred begs for the truth. “Are you an Eye?” she asks. Answer? “Yes.”

EMILY’S LAST STAND | Offred, NuOfglen and Ofsteven are all shopping at an open-air market the next day when Offred gets a moment alone with her friend. She wants to know more about Mayday, but all she really learns is Ofsteven’s real name — which we already know is Emily — before NuOfglen hastily shuts down the exchange.

But though the aunts may have taken Ofsteven’s lady parts, they’ll never take her freedom! So she sees an opportunity and seizes it, deftly hopping into an open car and driving away while the other handmaids look on in awe/amusement. But ish gets real when she backs into some guards, knocking one down, and then she gives Offred a long look, then floors the gas and runs the guard over in spectacularly bloody fashion. It’s only a matter of time, then, before the rest of the armed goons break the window, drag her out and hurl her into the back of a van.

WOMAN ON TOP | Later, after imagining herself plunging a sharp garden tool into Serena’s jugular, Offred realizes that her friend had won — despite everything that had happened to her. “They didn’t get everything. There was something inside her they couldn’t take away. She looked invincible,” Offred voiceovers, using a word Luke once said described her.

Galvanized by that thought, Offred brazenly marches downstairs, knocks on Nick’s door and begins undressing him. Then she takes off her own clothes — except, for some reason, the socks! — and they go at it on his bed, for real this time. It’s everything their prior encounter was not (namely: hot), particularly when Offred rolls them over so she’s on top. That’s right, bitches: June is in the house.

Your turn. What did you think of the episode? Sound off in the comments!

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Lysh says:

    I was enjoying the Scabble and the dumb magazine, trying to make things bearable for Offred, so it was disappointing to hear he’s really truly awful. Also June being the other woman in Luke’s first marriage. Emily in the car was the best though!
    This show is horrifying and yet I’m kinda obsessed. Congrats to Hulu; I’m probably going to go past my free month subscription because of this show.

  2. abz says:

    This show is so disturbing and haunting and I binged the first four episodes in one sitting. It makes my heart ache. I never read the book, but I so want Ofglen (or Ofsteven) to be okay. Alexis Bledel has been amazing. I loved her as Rory Gilmore, but her acting on this show is on another level. The entire cast has been superb.
    I knew the Commander was a horrible person, but I kept hoping maybe he be different.
    The Good Fight, Legion, Feud, Big Little Lies, 13 Reasons Why, Sense8, and now The Handmaids Tale among many others. Seriously 2017 has been an amazing year for television so far and we’re not even halfway through the year. The Emmys especially the Best Actresses category is gonna be a bloodbath.

    • AlliDone says:

      I totally recommend reading the book. I recently reread it, mostly because the first time I read the book was in 1997 (when I was 12) and didn’t fully understand the concept of it. This is the book that inspired the person I am today. It also has one of the greatest ‘endings’ in fiction.

      Also, you’re right, the actress categories are going to be an extremely tough call just to narrow down the nominees, let alone an actual winner. I really love that television is truly being embraced as the amazing long-form medium it is for storytelling. We still have a good 7 months of programming left of 2017 that includes the penultimate season of Game of Thrones and the final season of Orphan Black.

  3. AlliDone says:

    I reread the book shortly before the series started as kind of a refresh (and also there’s a lot in that book that a 12 year old girl’s brain just couldn’t comprehend). As I was re-reading it felt so chilling and relevant now, even though it was written in 1985 (coincidentally the year of my birth). The series does so much more justice to the book than the film ever did.
    Hulu has done such an amazing job pulling this show into, not only a modern age, but also into a time where the concerns of this is actually present. Politically speaking this show is incredibly relevant and Hulu (and Bruce Miller) was incredibly prescient in producing this show since production began long before we fully entered into our current political climate (in fact, they announced the beginning of production in April 2016).
    The Handmaid’s Tale is a chilling piece of ‘speculative’ fiction that we all must be vigilant against.

  4. Sarah says:

    Loved this episode. So much good stuff happening. Kinda confused why Nick admitted he was an eye. I won’t spoil the book ending but I’m hoping it’s still along those lines for why.
    Go Emily!!! Seriously loved that scene I wish she could have got away. I hope we see more from her. But knowing gilead..they’ll probably kill her. Alexis Bledel is truely perfect and brilliant in this role.

    • AlliDone says:

      I’m a little confused about the changes from the book as well since it was left so ambiguous in the book. I’m trusting, at this point, that things will flow along the same lines as well since Margaret Atwood is a supervising producer.

  5. oldskool fan says:

    I felt making her “the other woman” or the type of woman who would coyly asks a lover to divorce his wife, was a good twist. So now its a bit hard to have much respect for her previous character as developing affairs with married men would have been considered the ultimate in betrayal to the “sisterhood” or “girl code”, practised at the time previous to Gilead The nu Ofglen hinted about seeing her in the museum park and there is something that makes you a little weary of her yet at the same time she is strong minded and savy. It raises questions that maybe for some women Gilead was a better place as it offered security in the form of a bed and food. I also agree that the handmaids tale could continue with other handmaids continuing the story.