James Corden, Anne Hathaway Perform 5-Minute Rom-Com Musical — Watch

James Corden won’t be hosting the Tony Awards this year — but his newest Late Late Show musical just might be worthy of a nomination.

On Thursday’s episode of the talker, Corden and guest Anne Hathaway staged an entire romantic comedy musical in just five-and-a-half minutes, working in songs by Selena Gomez, Jason Mraz and Al Green, among others.

Along the way, Corden and Hathaway’s characters go from a meet cute in the elevator, to sharing an apartment, to… well, we won’t spoil what happens in the middle. (But Hathaway’s drunken performance of “All By Myself” is award-worthy in its own right.)

Press PLAY on the video above to see Corden and Hathaway’s musical, then hit the comments and tell us what you thought!