Legion Recap: Gunfire and Ice

Need to catch up? Check out the previous Legion recap here.

Were you hoping that things would start to make sense this week on Legion? Well… my condolences. But we did see some action!

David’s still stuck in that sedated dream from last week, and even Ptonomy can’t seem to pinpoint where his mind is, saying he’s “somewhere between memory and a dream.” Melanie wants to know how David ended up in Clockworks, so Syd, Ptonomy and Kerry go snoop around his old therapist Dr. Poole’s office. Ptonomy finds the doctor’s tape recorder all busted up, and searches it for memories. (Yeah, he can do that with objects, too.) He sees a vision of Dr. Poole badly wounded, with David standing over him. Syd doesn’t want to believe her beloved David could do something like that. Ptonomy, well… he thinks maybe he could.

RELATED Legion Recap: Sweet Dreams

Syd also learns a little more about Kerry: namely, that she and Cary don’t just share a name; they share a body. (We saw a hint of that last week with Kerry entering Cary’s body.) Kerry seems OK with it, though: “He does the boring stuff… I get all the action.” Plus, she only ages when she’s outside his body, which is a pretty sweet deal. And we learn that Melanie’s husband has been preserved in ice, frozen inside an old-timey underwater diving suit. Melanie cradles his body and weeps: “Come back to us.” Maybe he’s in suspended animation, like Walt Disney’s head?

Legion Episode 4 David PtonomyAlright, so where the heck is David? Well, he’s drifting through some kind of alternate dimension, walking on a sea of glowing green dots. He sees a guy in that same diving suit and follows him up a ladder to an ice-covered bachelor pad. The guy is Oliver (Jemaine Clement), who offers David a drink and plays him some atonal free-jazz with squealing horns. Oliver tells David he’s now stuck in a place where every day is the same, and nothing is real. (If you’ve been watching Legion, you know the feeling!)

Oliver’s happy to finally have a companion: He excitedly recites some weird beat poetry for David and reassures him that “The Monster… can’t get you in here.” (We can see the Devil With the Yellow Eyes lurking outside the ice palace.) David just wants to leave, and figures since he’s a highly gifted mutant, he can just use his powers to get out. But after he comically flails for a while, Oliver just shows him a door, leaving him with these parting words: “It’s not real, unless you make it real.”

Meanwhile, Syd and Ptonomy visit David’s ex Philly at her realty office, posing as home buyers so Ptonomy can scan her memories. He finds a memory of Philly tracking down Dr. Poole at a lighthouse, and that’s enough for him — but Syd keeps pressing Philly about David. Philly says he was sweet, but he had this no-good friend named Benny. No, not Lenny: Benny, a guy. And when Syd asks if Philly has any message for David, she says, “Tell him… they’re watching.”

They head to the lighthouse to find a retired Dr. Poole, who confirms Philly’s story: Benny was indeed a guy, and had a “negative effect” on David’s treatment. But something’s off, and Kerry realizes: “It’s a trap.” Dr. Poole is actually The Eye (he can shape-shift?!), and Division 3 soldiers pummel the lighthouse with gunfire, forcing Syd and Ptonomy to flee upstairs. Kerry, who’s been itching for a fight this entire episode, is happy to finally see some action, hurling herself out a window to take on the soldiers.

Legion Episode 4 KerryThis leads to Legion‘s best action scene yet: As Feist’s ethereal rocker “Undiscovered First” plays underneath, Kerry karate-kicks the hell out of some soldiers while her bodymate Cary kicks along back at the lab. (They eventually get the best of her, though.) The Eye follows Syd and Ptonomy upstairs, and when Ptonomy fires bullets at him at point-blank range, The Eye just keeps walking. He puts his hand on Ptonomy’s skull, knocking him out, but when he turns to Syd, she takes off her gloves and touches her hand to his. Body-switch time! When soldiers arrive, “The Eye” (really Syd) tells them to put “Syd” (really The Eye) in their van. “Syd” tries to explain, but “The Eye” kicks her in the face, knocking her out.

David’s still in dreamland, and Lenny’s taunting him again, showing him a vision of The Eye looming over Syd with a knife to get him riled up. It does the trick, because David freaks, and teleports himself to the woods, where he forces The Eye’s van to careen off the road and crash. He thinks he’s rescuing Syd, and hands her a knife — but she’s really The Eye! “She” leans in to stab David in the back, but just in time, “The Eye” flings a knife at her, knocking the knife out of her hand.

“Syd” runs off down the road, with David and “The Eye” giving chase. David tackles “The Eye”… but then “he” morphs back into Syd. The Eye, back in his own body, pulls out a gun and fires, hitting Kerry in the shoulder. (Cary suffers along with her, back in the lab.) As she lies bleeding on the ground, Ptonomy rushes to her aid, and David sits stunned… as Lenny’s hand creeps up his shoulder.

X-tra Thoughts:

* So yeah, I wouldn’t say this episode “made sense”… but it was a lot of fun, wasn’t it? It delivered the kind of kick-ass action we (and Kerry) have been waiting for — and I’m always a sucker for Jemaine Clement.

* My theory: This guy Benny has some connection to the Devil With the Yellow Eyes. Didn’t he kind of look like a less bloated version of the Devil? Maybe David accidentally killed him with his powers, and that guilt is haunting him?

* Also worth noting: that prison-cell conversation between Amy and David’s Clockworks therapist Dr. Kissinger. So David’s childhood beagle King never existed?! So can we trust anything we think we know about David’s past, including his parents?

* We already know The Eye is a mutant; Melanie said he used to be at Summerland. And it looks like his powers include shape-shifting, invincibility and some kind of Vulcan neck-pinch finishing move. But how did he end up going over to the dark side?

* I wouldn’t mind hanging out and having a cocktail with Oliver in his groovy Fortress of Solitude. But please, Ollie: Let someone else choose the music.

Wanna help us make sense of tonight’s Legion? (Please?) Drop your thoughts in a comment below.

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

21 Comments
  1. AngelWasHere says:

    I always feel like I’m high or drunk while watching this show. It’s starting to lose me. :/

  2. Ian says:

    That fight scene with Kerry and Cary was cool, but it was also ridiculous. Some episodes have been incredible, but this one crossed over into being a bad cartoon.

  3. jrex says:

    It looked like at some points David might actually be the “devil with yellow eyes” or thinks he is.

  4. Quinten says:

    I guess I don’t understand the confusion. The storytelling is definitely told in a much different format than any other tv show currently on air. But it’s not like it didn’t make sense? I’m entirely confident the writers know what they’re leading to.

  5. James D says:

    I’m loosing interest in this show quickly. they need to cool it with the David lynch stuff this is not Eraserhead, and start with an actual coherent story, sorry to be harsh but the convoluted mess is starting to irk me.

  6. leo says:

    Blame Mr. Robot for this. Suddenly, a confusing storylines is considered a good story.

  7. Debbie says:

    I enjoyed this episode. It reminded me of the BBC series Life on Mars. I believe The Eye has mind control and was able to make them think they were talking to the doctor instead of him shape shifting into the doctor, that would also explain why he was able to knock Ptonomy out when he touched him, it was a duel of similar mental powers. The fight scene was well done, I loved the way that it was cut with the movements of Bill Irwin back at Summerland. He’s always been a very physical performer, nice to see it being put to use again. Unlocking this story is as complex as the character of David is himself. I look forward to future episodes.

    • Cat says:

      I’m liking this show so far. I was also a big fan of the BBC’s “Life on Mars” and its continuation in “Ashes to Ashes”.

  8. partisan says:

    I really wanted to like this show but the whole “weird for weird sake” thing is starting to get really tedious. They obviously want to keep the audience guessing but I’m guessing they’ve got maybe 2-3 more episodes before I abandon this the way I did mr robot. If this sort of thing is your cup of tea then enjoy with my full blessing, but for me this is just an incoherent mess that’s probably not actually going anywhere.

  9. QueenB says:

    Lenny aka Benny is the Devil with the Yellow Eyes who I also believe is the Shadow King. The Shadow King took control of Benny in an attempt to control and or take over David and got trapped on the astral plane and is now apart of David since it hitchhiked its way out of the astral plane with David

  10. justsomeguy says:

    This show is a mess.

  11. sunshine says:

    I was giving it until this week to start to make sense and actually get somewhere. Now I think it will always be a story about David’s twitchy character and weird dreams. Not really sure I can bring myself to try again next week.

  12. Carla Krae says:

    The Eye might project what he wants you to see, vs. being a shapeshifter. Too early to say.

  13. Carla Krae says:

    Show totally makes sense. Legion – David – always had multiple personality disorder in his comic stories. This episode showed that the most as the outsiders started to piece together what David’s real history is. It’s common and typical for one personality to not have the memories of a different personality. David could easily be rewriting his memories to be able to live with the things his worse personality does.

    • Lahru says:

      This is a good re-imagining of a great character. David/Legion has always been complex. Not only does he have multiple personalities, he absorbs other people’s personas. That is their minds; & they all vie for control. This has been happening to him since he was a little boy. He also has telepathy, telekinesis, & other powers. Stack it all together & your looking at a major mind job. The show is going to be confusing, if it isn’t, you’re not telling David’s story correctly. As an audience we want answers, but be patient, they’ll come in due time, but we suffer, because David suffers. That’s just how his world is.

  14. Of the people complaining about the storyline, I wonder how many are fans of David Waller from the comic books. He has always been difficult to contain in normal narratives and I love the way the show is handling the character. This weeks episode continued to unravel his challenges and work more into the mystery of what he is going through. I firmly believe Yellow is the Shadow King seeking revenge on poor David for his father’s (Professor Charles Xavier) actions. I look forward to the continued momentum on what the heck is going on