Legion FX Episode 3 David Syd

Legion Recap: Sweet Dreams

Need to catch up? Check out the previous Legion recap here.

Another week of Legion, another week of delving into the thicket of repressed angst that is David’s brain. But things got even wilder this week… and more dangerous for everyone involved.

David is still worried about his sister Amy, who’s being interrogated by that Phil Spector-looking creep, The Eye. But he dives back into more memory work with Melanie, who promises they’ll speed things up by focusing on big events. (“The s—t that scares you the most,” as Ptonomy puts it.) They zap back into David’s memory of that kitchen-utensil tornado, and Melanie sees it in full for the first time, with plates and bowls exploding into the air. She realizes he’s not just a telepath; he can control things with his mind. “Control may be an overstatement,” David grumbles.

They rewind to see what led to this, and find David and Lenny enjoying some “vapor” when his girlfriend Philly walks in on them. But then Ptonomy starts to vibrate. “He’s resisting again,” he tells Melanie. Then David spots the Devil With the Yellow Eyes and freaks out, and suddenly they’re all sitting back in Summerland again — but in a different room. Ptonomy marvels that David managed to teleport them “six hundred feet, through two solid walls.” He finally asks David, “What are you?!”

Legion Episode 3 Aubrey Plaza LennyTo find out, Cary straps David into a chair, sticks sensors on his face and injects him with a dye, all to model David’s brain waves. Cary tells him to think of something stressful (uh-oh), and David flashes back to a childhood Halloween where the main character from that children’s book, The World’s Angriest Boy in the World, comes to life and chases after him. Plus, Lenny appears in the lab and taunts David, telling him “commandos are gang-banging your sister” while he’s busy working on his feelings. This sends David into freak-out mode: The lab’s lights turn red and the controls fritz out as David begins levitating (!), drawing him and Syd into a glowing ball of white light (?). Whoa.

Somehow, David and Syd have teleported to Amy’s interrogation room, where they watch a guy from Division Three yell at Amy to help him find David “so I can turn him off.” They’re not physically there, but The Eye sees them and even reaches out to touch them before they disappear. They rematerialize in a lake at Summerland, and Syd tells David that if he ever gains control of his powers, “you’re gonna be a world-class badass.”

Melanie warns them about The Eye, saying the guy (then known as “Walter”) was one of the first mutants her husband brought into Summerland, but “he wanted to hurt people.” She insists on sedating David to get access to his mind without him resisting, and she, Ptonomy and Syd zap back to the incident that landed David in Clockworks. They’re joined in Memory World by a child version of David, since his adult rational brain is asleep. And since Syd can actually touch people in this realm, Child David gives her a big hug. Aw! (Hey, we have to take our little pleasures where we can find them on this show.)

Legion Episode 3 SydBut things don’t stay adorable for long: While they watch David break into his therapist’s office to steal stuff, Syd has nasty visions of David eating audio tape and a huge red crack opening in the wall with demonic hands coming out of it. Then Child David runs off, and Syd chases him through hallways and into a heating vent. She looks back to see the World’s Angriest Boy pursuing them, and then the Devil With the Yellow Eyes. It’s all so intense that Syd wakes herself up screaming. She wakes up Ptonomy, who asks her what happened. “Yeah, we’re gonna have a long conversation about that,” she says.

Melanie’s still in there, and it gets weird for her, too: She enters David’s childhood bedroom and finds the World’s Angriest Boy book. She’s horrified by the violent text and images — and then the book slams shut on her hand. She screams, the Devil With the Yellow Eyes floats behind her, her hand becomes a gnarled claw… and she wakes up screaming. But her hand’s back to normal. And David continues sleeping, with nightmarish visions of people surrounding him and screaming at him.

So here’s where I put on my critic’s cap for a minute: Doesn’t this show feels like it’s been stuck in neutral the last two weeks? I adored the pilot, and I still love all the visual flair and surreal weirdness we’ve seen so far. But what has it all added up to, besides confusion? Have we learned anything about David that we didn’t already know after the pilot? Next week’s Episode 4 is a big one for me: I really want to see the story expand beyond David’s mind and involve some real-world consequences, so I can get invested again. Because otherwise, this show is just full of garbled psychology and cool CGI, signifying nothing.

X-tra Thoughts:

Legion FX Episode 3 Melanie Bird* I did love Melanie’s morning chat with the coffee maker, elegantly voiced by Flight of the Conchords alum Jemaine Clement. That’s her husband, who helped found Summerland and whose voice is all over the facility. And notice she didn’t tell Syd that her husband died. So maybe we’ll get to see Clement in the flesh by season’s end?

* Aubrey Plaza always gives this show a nice energy boost whenever Lenny’s on the screen. “Unhand the reptile, space captain!”

* David and Syd’s body-switch talk got a little… graphic, didn’t it? But I enjoyed her Zen perspective on her powers putting her in a hundred different bodies: “Everywhere I go, I’m me.”

* In the Halloween flashback, was young David dressed as Louis Tully, the Rick Moranis character from Ghostbusters? I couldn’t tell for sure, but that colander on the head looked familiar.

Are you frustrated with Legion’s slow pace so far? Or are you still digging the vibe, man? Drop your thoughts in a comment below.

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

12 Comments
  1. AngelWasHere says:

    Good episode! This show feels a big roller coaster of craziness. Didn’t think anything could outdo Preacher in weirdness. Good weirdness, but weird all the same.

  2. Arthur Dent says:

    We were just commenting that the plot is dragging a bit — still establishing how weird / scary David’s mind and memories are. No big new clues on the Yellow Eyed Demon or the origins of the creepy book. And Aubrey Plaza is a scene-stealing machine. “Unhand the reptile, Space Captain” is one for the ages.

    One thing — is the “X” in the window at Summerland an X-Men reference?

  3. Ian says:

    I so adore Syd. I love her. Rachel Keller’s got another huge fan.

  4. are you sure this show is for you if you think that it is stuck in neutral zone and you are not that invested anymore ? I don’t know about you but I am so invested in this tv show at this point and I watched a lot of sci fi movies and tv shows in my life … but this one is extremely good so far … I like every part of it. … I also love the psychology part … I don’t need them to go back to reality or consequences … staying like that it’s perfect for me.

  5. Alichat says:

    I loved the first two episodes, but I have to agree about this third episode dragging a bit. It needed to drive the plot forward more, and it didn’t. I was hoping we’d see his parents…..or discover why we can’t see their faces. Or more would be revealed in his sister’s ‘interrogation’. Or we’d learn something about the book. To be fair, we did learn a bit more about some characters like Walter, Cary, and Melanie. The location jumps were awesome to see visually, and that last memory visit was weird and creepy. (Was that his parents having sex?) And I enjoyed the conversation between Syd and David about when they switched bodies. (you found it graphic??) I thought it demonstrated David’s willingness to talk with or share with Syd, even if he blocks everyone else from discovering things about himself. But I was really expecting them to focus more on finding Amy. Perhaps trying to figure out where she is from David and Syd’s jump to the room. Or perhaps Syd trying to draw a picture of the demon eyed man. She keeps seeing it…..which makes me think that since they body switched, she can see all the things only he keeps seeing. Hopefully more action will happen next week that doesn’t take place in his mind.

    • Darren says:

      It’s him having sex with his ex girlfriend, not his parents. Guys, you complain about the show dragging but some people here obviously have too short of an attention span to follow.

      • Alichat says:

        I have watched the episode twice and couldn’t make out who was having sex due to the darkness in the shot. And since he was a child and we’d seen his parents (but not their faces) a lot in the memories, I wondered if it was his parents. Perhaps you should know all the facts before making incorrect assumptions.

  6. justsomeguy says:

    Couldn’t agree more about the show dragging at this point. All of this crazy stuff in this guy’s head is cool, but I don’t think they needed 2 episodes to tell this part of their story. I’m not saying he needs to learn to control his powers in 3 episodes, but this episode should have advanced the story in some way. Next week’s episode for me determines if I keep watching.

  7. Lisa says:

    I love the fact that this is a thriller staged inside a guy’s mind. I don’t need any real-world consequences. This search for truth, and the mysteries, all inside David’s head is uniquely satisfying for me.

  8. lypscratch says:

    I am absolutely loving it! The pace is perfect for me. We just finished ep 3. I was blown away. Sat there like a kid watching Santa leaving presents around the tree just before he snarfs the cookies and milk I left out for him. Like I was watching magic hatching. I want to watch again right now!!