Pretty Little Liars: NFL Players Reenact 'The Jenna Thing' on Tonight Show

If Troian Bellisario and Sasha Pieterse ever get tired of their gigs on Pretty Little Liars, they’ve got two (very large) replacements waiting in the wings.

New York Jets quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick and New York Giants cornerback Prince Amukamara stopped by The Tonight Show on Wednesday to reenact a scene from the ABC Family Freeform drama, with Fitzpatrick slipping into the role of Spencer and Amukamara donning Alison’s iconic golden locks.

Not only is the whole scenario super ridiculous, but it also works as a nice little #TBT for longtime fans of the show; the footballers perform a scene from Season 1, back when “the Jenna thing” was still, you know, a thing.

Hit PLAY on the video above, then drop a comment below: Do Fitzpatrick and Amukamara need to get their tight ends to Rosewood ASAP?