Freshman TV Report Card

Fall TV Winners & Losers: Are the New Shows You Like Best Sticking Around?

Throughout the fall, TVLine asked you to grade each of the new pilots — from Minority Report and Bastard Executioner, which were among the first out of the gate, to the more recent Supergirl and Jessica Jones debuts.

As the numbers started coming in, did you prove to be prescient with your predictions or wildly off the mark?

Last year, The Flash, How to Get Away With Murder, American Horror Story: Freak Show, Red Band Society (beeeeeeeeeep….) and A to Z (R.I.P.) populated your Top 5, while Mulaney and Utopia deservedly brought up the very rear.

TVLine took a precise hand-count of your votes and extrapoconvertulated it into a numerical grade, with “100” representing a perfect score.

How did your knee-jerk impressions compare to each newcomer’s eventual fate? And who led this freshman class? Review the slideshow below (click here for direct access), arranged from lowest grade to highest.