American Crime Story: Cuba Gooding, Jr. as O.J. Simpson & More Cast Photos

Warning: The photos you’re about to see can never be unseen — not that you’d want them to.

FX this week released the official cast photos from Ryan Murphy’s O.J. Simpson-centric American Crime Story, including Horror Story vet Sarah Paulson in her most unrecognizable role yet.

As head prosecutor Marcia Clark, Paulson trades her long locks for a tight mane of curls — but who wore them better, Paulson or Tina Fey in Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt?

David Schwimmer (Friends) as the late Robert Kardashian, O.J.’s close friend and defense attorney, is also a delight. That hair? Very Maxwell Sheffield.

And don’t think we forgot about John Travolta as Robert Shapiro, also a member of Simpson’s defense team. (We just got lost in his eyes for a second.)

Browse our gallery of Crime Story‘s primary cast members below, then drop a comment with your first impressions.