Reality Check: Who's the American Idol Front-Runner Now? And Was the Judges' Save Used Righteously?

It’s a week of deep disagreement here at Reality Check — as my co-host Melinda Doolittle and I can’t seem to agree on who’s leading American Idol‘s Season 14 pack.

Jax or Joey? Clark or Quentin? Heck, we can’t even solve the question of J.Hud or (brace for a blast from the past) Zoanette!

Fret not, though — we’re not engaging in any kind of Cookie Vs. Boo-Boo Kitty brawling. And actually, there’s one subject on which we’ve found common ground: the decision to use the Judges’ Save on Qaasim Middleton.

Press PLAY for the full Reality Check discussion — including the week’s biggest disappointments and the perils of song choice — then hit the comments with your thoughts!