SNL Boss Lorne Michaels on the Big Names (Carell!) He Turned Away

Saturday Night Live Lorne Michaels Steve Carell

“No one gets it all right.”

As Saturday Night Live‘s 40th anniversary broadcast approaches, series svengali Lorne Michaels is revealing some of the famous names he rejected early in their careers.

Among those turned away from Studio 8H: The Office‘s Steve Carell and incoming Late Show host Stephen Colbert.

UPDATE: Per Carell’s Twitter feed Thursday, the comedian never auditioned for SNL.

VIDEO J.K. Simmons Hosts Saturday Night Live: Watch the Best and Worst Sketches

“There were lots of people who you’d see how brilliant they were, but you knew on some level that it wasn’t going to work,” he tells The Hollywood Reporter.

Lisa Kudrow, Kathy Griffin, and Jim Carrey also are part of the Not Right for the Not Ready for Primetime Players club.

VIDEO Heroes Reborn Trailer: Zachary Levi’s Character Unmasked in Teaser Trailer

Michaels also tells the site that he wasn’t at Carrey’s tryout, but went with someone’s advice that he wouldn’t like the comedian’s style.

“They were probably wrong, but it doesn’t matter,” he says. “Or maybe they were right — who knows?”

The long-running comedy series’ live anniversary special will air Sunday, Feb. 15, at 8/7c on NBC.