Pretty Little Liars Photos: A Fight With Toby Leaves Spencer in Tears

Pretty Little Liars Spoilers

Toby’s finally cast-free and mobile when Pretty Little Liars returns in January — but why is he using his legs to run from Spencer?

New photos from the ABC Family drama’s Jan. 13 episode find the formerly rock-solid Spoby on shaky ground, as Toby chooses to walk away from a crying Spencer on the streets of Rosewood.

So, why the lovers’ quarrel? The answer lies in the episode’s official description, per ABC Family: “When a surprising bit of evidence shows up, Toby is put in a difficult position with his job and with Spencer. … Spencer tries to convince Toby to stray from his moral gut reaction, which puts stress on their relationship.”

And here I thought “Officer Toby” was going to be a good thing.

We’ve also got photos from PLL‘s Jan. 20 episode, in which the girls turn to Caleb for a little technical assistance in their ongoing battle against “A.”

Oh, and did I mention the new batch of pics includes the returns of Jason and Ashley? Always good to see their faces — especially after Jason’s nasty run-in with that elevator shaft.

PLL fans, are you worried about Spencer and Toby? Browse the new photos below, then drop a comment with your thoughts.