How to Get Away With Murder: Who Killed Sam? Check Out Our Odds!

Sam Keating: Handsome. Duplicitious. And very, very dead.

Yep, we all know How to Get Away With Murder‘s cheating professor winds up bludgeoned, set ablaze and ultimately dismembered in the woods, but tonight’s winter finale will reveal whodunnit — and why.

Was it his scorned wife? Could it have been her moony-eyed right-hand woman? What about the one they call The Puppy?

We’ve gathered up a list of 10 suspects, sifted through their motivations and their Murder Night whereabouts and set their odds of having done the deed.

Click through the gallery below for our take on “Who Killed Sam?,” then hit the comments with your thoughts and theories!