On tonight’s Faking It (MTV, 10:30/9:30c), Karma (played by American Idol alum Katie Stevens) takes to the stage and whips out her guitar to confess her feelings — but her tune isn’t about fake girlfriend/real bestie Amy.
As Karma croons about her secret lover in the following exclusive video, her gal pal isn’t the only one who starts to catch on to the song’s true inspiration.
Press PLAY to watch the sneak peek, then hit the comments with your thoughts on the ode and poor Amy’s crushed face. (P.S. — TVLine readers Elle and Lauren win for nailing who Rita Volk, aka Amy, looks like: a blonde Sasha (Julia Goldani Telles) from Bunheads. Ladies, please collect your brownie points in the comments.)