Pretty Little Liars Sneak Peek: Emily and Paige's Biggest Fight Yet -- Is a Breakup Imminent?

Paily fans, you might want to light a few candles before watching this scene from Tuesday’s Pretty Little Liars.

RELATED | Pretty Little Liars Recap: Mommy Fearest

When Emily realized that Paige tipped off the police about Alison being alive, you knew it was only a matter of time before she confronted her about it. Well, tick-tock, it looks like the confrontation is happening even sooner than we expected.

In this explosive clip from Tuesday’s episode (8/7c, ABC Family), the girls’ bathroom at Rosewood High School becomes a battleground for Emily and Paige to sort out their issues — and by “sort out,” I mean go at each other Mean Girls-style.

Could this be the beginning (eh, more like the middle) of the end for Paily? Hit PLAY on the preview below, then drop a comment with your thoughts on the couple’s future… or lack thereof.

Loading video...



Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

51 Comments
  1. alistaircrane says:

    I don’t like these two together. Emily’s best love interest was Samara.

    • Hannah Jane says:

      I couldn’t agree more. It also doesn’t help that Paige, y’know, tried to kill Emily when they were on the swim team together, but that seems to have been totally forgotten….

      • Beth says:

        Paige dunked Emily’s head underwater, she didn’t try to drown her. And she was remorseful right after, Emily knew that & forgave her. Everyone seems to forget Ali tortured the whole town, and is the worst possible choice for a love interest for Emily.

      • Azerty says:

        Well Paige tried to drown Emily, Caleb was hired by Jenna to spy on Hannah, Toby faked his death that lead Spencer to Radley and Ezra…well don’t get me started on Ezra. But those girls seem to forget a lot of things actually.

    • Jillian says:

      EXACTLY. Too bad Claire Holt has The Originals now

    • Kat says:

      Samara was SO boring. Maybe it was just the actress that was just really wooden or something, but she was basically a mannequin. Emily can have girls lining up to date her, she doesn’t need to settle for anyone yet. Idk, but whatever happens, they need to have her move on from caring so much about that bitch Ali- in fact, they all need to, she’s literally the worst person.

  2. Diz says:

    Good. These 2 are horrible together. Emily can do much better for herself.

  3. spindae2 says:

    I loved these 2 together but Emily doesn’t deserve Paige. Paige went such a long way and did so many things for Em but she is still infatuated with Ally and doesn’t deserve better at this point. I hope the Paige actress moves on to another show she deserves better ;-)

    • Jillian says:

      Lets not forget that Paige tried to drown Emily.

      • paily says:

        Actually confirmed by the writer of the episode that it was a scare tactic. Paige apologized for it, they both moved on. [unlike toby driving Spencer crazy to the point of being committed and never apologized and don’t even get me started on Ezra]

      • Liz says:

        If that was Paige trying to kill Emily then I don’t think anyone has anything to fear from Paige. Furthermore your statement implies that anytime someone holds someone else’s head underwater it’s attempted murder… I think the majority of older brothers in america would have something to fear if that was the case.

  4. Riana says:

    Still hoping for Emily and Ali to kiss in the finale.

  5. Julia says:

    Paige needs to date someone better for her. What confuses me is that Lindsey is confirmed for season 5, but what point would Paige have on the show if Emily and Paige broke up?

  6. kara says:

    Paige is so useless and pointless. Send her packing. Either rise Maya from the grave or hook Alison up with Emily.

  7. kat says:

    Paige is the worst. Uh, she tried to kill Emily, has been lying about all kinds of stuff this whole time and now betrayed all of them. Also, she has a weird face and/or hair.

  8. Meredith says:

    I’m sorry. I thought these two already broke up after Paige threw Emily that horrible surprise party. Paige has barely been in any episodes since then. Did I miss when they got back together?

  9. Clara Oswin Oswald says:

    At first I really liked Paige, but now I can’t stand her. She tries to hard and Emily doesn’t seem to be too much into this relationship . They just don’t fit together.

  10. Jen says:

    I hope they break up. Simply because she is useless and pointless… just like all of their love interests. Toby hasn’t been interesting for a long time. They finally made him interesting by being apart of the “A Team,” but of course, they couldn’t upset all their precious 12 year old fans. So they wimped out of that one. Then they give him so ridiculous, pointless storyline about his mother, which went nowhere and nobody cared about. Ezra has been pointless since like Season 2 and they FINALLY made him interesting. Oh but wait, they yet again wimped out and went down an easy route. Making Ezra write a book was disappointing. Caleb is useless as well, for various reasons. All of their love interests really don’t have much of a point on the show. They are used specifically to be love interests and nothing else, which is annoying and disappointing.

  11. R. says:

    I think so much of the hate for Paige is so unfounded. Yeah, she dunked Emily under the water that one time to freak her out, but the girl was barely surviving under the weight of her self hatred, it wasn’t surprising she’d act out like that. But she apologized. Thoroughly. And Emily clearly forgave her. Whereas Toby being A (which is much, much worse) was basically brushed under the rug, never mentioned again, and no one in the fandom seems to care. And don’t even get me started on the Ezria shippers. If Emily was straight and the Paige character was a straight boy, I doubt any of this hate would ever have been directed towards her.

  12. Emgee says:

    I love Paige and Emily together, but this is a huge betrayal. She basically forced the truth out of Emily and then ran out and shouted a confidence from the rooftops. I’m not sure I’m ready for them to break up, but Paige owes a huge apology to, not just Emily, but all four girls.

    • Liz says:

      Seriously though, Paige did the right thing. I mean these girls keep getting into trouble because they don’t trust each other when they should, and they don’t seek help. And why? To protect Ali, the girl who tortured and tormented them and their loved ones… Paige has already almost been killed because of Emily’s stupid decisions, I think she’s fully justified in not keeping this secret.

  13. Beth says:

    Paige is the only one that has any sense, and she did the right thing going to the cops. Emily can’t see that Ali is a manipulator, and is only going to hurt her & the other liars. Paige is the best girlfriend in the world sadly some people are shallow, and don’t see all the wrong Ali does.

  14. Laura says:

    I wish Emily would just drop Paige. Paige can’t keep her word and is willing to put someones life at risk and stab her gf in the back.

  15. Hannah says:

    I don’t think they will break-up frankly because Lindsey Shaw is back for season 5, but that’s not to say there won’t be any tension because that’s inevitable. If Paige’s background was dealt with in more detail and the writers actually treated her character like they do with all the other love interests it would explain a hell of a lot about her character and why she does things. First of all the fact that Paige has liked/loved Emily since before Ali’s death and even before Ali found out and started blackmailing her (the letter) confirms that she’s doing this out of love for Emily and she really just wants to protect her. Why give up her relationship with Emily, something she has hoped for, for years, for the sake of getting revenge on Alison? It doesn’t make sense. Remember Emily doesn’t know about the letter in that flashback scene, Cece only told Spencer. Emily knows that Ali pushed Paige to self-harm and consider suicide, although it’s seems she has forgotten that aspect about Paige’s past or else she just doesn’t care, because knowing the girl who tortured, blackmailed and tormented you so much you considered taken your own life, is actually alive, cannot be an easy thing to hear.

    • Beth says:

      I really hope that letter resurfaces in S5 or Spencer tells Emily about the letter. It could very well open Emily’s eyes. Paige loves Emily, and she is protecting her, she is blinded by Ali. She takes Ali’s word in one meeting that Ali is sorry for all she did, Emily wants to believe it, sadly I don’t think Ali is remorseful.

  16. Maria says:

    Well Paige really love Emily and I dont think so she did it just for revenche. If I was in Paige shoes I will do it the same to protect my love one. Beside Lindsey Shaw is a superbe actress she deserve better with storyline about Paige will see it on S5

  17. Bella says:

    Ugh… I have always hated Paige. Our first impression of her is: a goody two shoes that listened to whatever her parents said, took out her anger and jealousy on Emily, trying to drown her, not being able to admit that she’s gay. Paige had a great character development because she is not afraid of calling herself gay/lesbian, really loves Emily, and speaks up for herself. But now their relationship is very lackluster and boring. We never got the, “awwww” of how great their relationship was. Paige and Emily’s relationship went from bad to even worse. I don’t see how the writers can develop their love story or Paige’s character any deeper than it is.

    • leelee says:

      Maybe Paige is A Team bound and trying to have the cops find her for the a team and get revenge then. A has always been the least likely suspect AND a love interest and I still don’t buy Ezra as being not A. The book can just be a part of it writers can become obsessive about their “work” too and get caught up in their subjects.

    • suh says:

      Paige is loving and she cares for emily. She was bullyed by allison she even thought of suicide. She was in a dark place. Her father just wanting for her to be perfect in every way. She was controled by her father and bullyed in school. I believe she even cut herself in that time. She tried to drown emily because she hated herself for having homossexual feelings thowards her. She saw that emily was free gay. And taking the only think that she had control. Being the best at swim team. She took a lot of time to love herself be confortable in her own skin. She is the most normal of the liars. She loves emily. She allways has. And i believe that emily and paige are ment to be together. Thing about it. All the reasons why she did what she did!! Emily was lying in the first place. She was distant from paige. Of corse she doesnt care about allison. She is bad. Paige actions are normal

  18. Please let them break up for good!!! Worst PLL couple in the history of the show!!!
    Plus Emily can do so much better!!! Paige needs to go!!!

  19. suh says:

    Paige is loving and she cares for emily. She was bullyed by allison she even thought of suicide. She was in a dark place. Her father just wanting for her to be perfect in every way. She was controled by her father and bullyed in school. I believe she even cut herself in that time. She tried to drown emily because she hated herself for having homossexual feelings thowards her. She saw that emily was free gay. And taking the only think that she had control. Being the best at swim team. She took a lot of time to love herself be confortable in her own skin. She is the most normal of the liars. She loves emily. She allways has. And i believe that emily and paige are ment to be together. Thing about it. All the reasons why she did what she did!! Emily was lying in the first place. She was distant from paige. Of corse she doesnt care about allison. She is bad. Paige actions are normal