Emmys 2013: Who Should Win Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy? Take Our Poll!

emmys-2013-guest-actress-comedyThe six ladies nominated for the 2013 Emmy for Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy all have an interesting thing in common: Each of ’em has been up for a statuette in prior years.

Only two of these women, however — Melissa McCarthy (as guest host of Saturday Night Live) and Glee‘s Dot-Marie Jones — were part of the Guest Actress race in 2012, both losing out to Kathy Bates (for Two and a Half Men). Jones, incidentally, was also nominated in the Guest Actress race in 2011, giving her a hat trick of nods.

RELATED | Emmys 2013: What Should Win Outstanding Comedy Series? Take Our Poll!

One other veteran of the category, Elaine Stritch, took home the Guest Actress in a Comedy statuette in 2007 for 30 Rock, but was relegated to bridesmaid staus in three subsequent nominations. With 30 Rock‘s seven-season run in the books, this will be Stritch’s last shot for playing the irascible Colleen Donaghy (though she has two prior Emmy wins — Guest Actress in a Drama in 1993 and Individual Performance in a Variety or Music Program in 2004).

RELATED | Veep‘s Anna Chlumsky Dishes Her Emmy Nomination, Favorite Profane Moments

While McCarthy is back in the mix for the second straight year for her SNL stint, two other actresses in the race also have connections to the NBC sketch-comedy show. Former cast regulars Molly Shannon and Kristen Wiig are both 2013 Guest Actress nominees: Shannon for her role on HBO’s Enlightened, Wiig for her first time out as an SNL host.

And finally, Melissa Leo — who’s landed both Primetime Emmy and Daytime Emmy nods in prior years — rounds out the field for her work on FX’s Louie.

What would you do if you had the power to honor one of these fine actresses when the Emmys are handed out? Take our poll below to vote for your favorite — TVLine voting closes Sept. 15, so act now! — then hit the comments to justify your pick!

Every day for the next month, we’ll launch another “Who Should Win?” Emmy poll, so come back to TVLine.com every day to weigh in on who’s most worthy of TV’s biggest honor. And to stay up to speed on all our races, follow me on Twitter @MichaelSlezakTV!

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. sookie says:

    Anything but glee, that show is trash now.

  2. Josh says:

    The thing is Dot Marie Jones’ guest stint on Glee wasn’t very funny, it was more of a dramatic role.

    • liz says:

      Agreed – but her performance was still excellent (and I’m no fan of Glee). I’d like to see her win; actresses like her so rarely get top-calibre recognition and she is really talented

      • She was good, but if you aren’t funny, aren’t trying to be funny and no laughter is resulted from your performance, you need to get the eff out of the comedy category. Period.

        • Its not really her decision, Glee is billed as a comedy, despite very much being a dramedy. The same thing happens at the Oscar’s.

          • RyanC says:

            I’m not sure the same thing does happen at the Oscars. They only really split the nominations by gender.

          • Lyn says:

            Another good example is “Nurse Jackie,” also a dramedy despite winning Edie Falco a bunch of “comedy” awards. “Sardonic” is not necessarily the same thing as “funny”!

        • liz says:

          Its not her fault she’s in that category; Glee competes in the comedy category. Just further proof that there needs to be a ‘dramedy’ section for the Emmy’s.

        • Josh says:

          That’s my point. There is no denying that she isn’t an award worthy actress, but she just isn’t worthy of THIS award. Her character was purely dramatic, she didn’t really have many funny moments.

    • cuius says:

      How does appearing in 30 episodes of Glee count as a “Guest Actress”?

  3. brycealexander says:

    Wow these choices suck

  4. Molly Shannon on Enlightened deserves everything. Anything that the show was nominated for should win, actually, which unfortunately only means Laura Dern and Shannon. They were both mesmerizing, fascinating and heartbreaking, especially Shannon’s part. “The Ghost is Seen” is one of the best episodes of the 2012-2013 TV season, and that is due to Mike White and Molly Shannon. It broke my heart and even got me teary-eyed.

  5. Bobby says:

    Molly Shannon please. Enlightened is my favorite season of TV this year and I hope it gets recognized in some way.

  6. Molly Shannon was great on Enlightened! Hope she wins.

  7. Seriously this is what the EMMY’s choose? Do those guys even watch TV, these are just big names on TV, not the best this year!

  8. GTS says:

    I loved Dot Marie Jones’ performance in Glee, but she wasnt being a comedic actress. In the episodes she showed her acting skills- her first kiss episode, the abusive relationship, and such, she was performing more dramatically.

    • Chris says:

      I don’t understand the time period that the Emmy’s nominate for…. all those storylines you mentioned were from Season 3–last year–not Season 4. Honestly I saw every episode this past year and can’t remember Dot having anything major to do.

  9. Benn says:

    While I agree Dot Marie Jones was a dramatic performance and that it’s unfortunate she is saddled in the comedy category, the distinction should be made that it’s actress in a comedy, not actress in a comedic role.

    I know, I know, that’s pulling hairs, but if we’re being specific, she was outstanding on a comedy with a dramatic performance. She deserves the nom, not sure about the win, though I’d like to see her do it.

    • Ari says:

      But Glee is also not a comedy. The only reason they are in the comedy category is because they are a musical and musicals get lumped in the comedy category,

      • Chris says:

        Not true…when Uma Thurman was nominated for Guest Actress on Smash last year…it was for Drama…not comedy. That only holds true for the Golden Globes.

    • it does say “Best Guest Actress in a Comedy” not “Best Comedic Performance by a Guest Actress” so she’s qualified, and i hope she gets it!

  10. Rjrtist says:

    Melissa McCarthy will win.

  11. Zoe says:

    Honestly, I’d have to root for Dot-Marie Jones. I remember her from my Glee-watching days, and I’d love to see her win. But honestly, I can’t see someone I don’t want to win- they’re all great actresses. But this season’s lackluster writing on SNL will probably work against Kristen Wiig and Melissa McCarthy.

  12. Philip says:

    Isn’t the category set deemed Best X Comedy or musical? Am I thinking of another awards show altogether?

    • Britta Unfiltered says:

      You’re thinking of the Golden Globes who do that. Uma Thurman for sure won guest actress in a drama for playing in Smash, so they had submitted themselves in the drama category. Musicals don’t have to be comedies at the Emmys.

  13. Soso says:

    I LOVE Kristen Wiig and she was just excellent all these years in SNL but I have to admit that Melissa McCarthy was just TREMENDOUSLY FUNNY as a host, and her episode was better than Wiig’s. So MELISSA MCARTHY ALL THE WAY !!!!

  14. Johnno Hooper says:

    Julia Louis-Dreyfus for Veep. No contest.

  15. Allen says:

    What did Dot Marie even do this year on Glee? All the first kiss, abusive relationship stuff was last season. I think I remember her being in the shooting episode, but that might not even be right.

  16. Austin says:

    Well, personally I think Molly Shannon deserves it if she hasn’t won an Emmy… if she has then I think Kristen Wiig deserves it.

  17. Joey says:

    I hope Melissa McCarthy or Kristen Wig win.

  18. Amanda says:

    I voted Dot-Marie because she’s just an amazing actress. Sure, she’s awesome at the comedy, but her dramatic episodes are intense.

  19. Toss up between McCarthy and Wiig.

  20. Britta Unfiltered says:

    Hey, you guys forgot to mention Melissa Leo also has an Oscar. I’ve had Melissa Leo picked to win this ever since that episode of Louie aired and I want her to win badly. I think she’s got it in the bag. She’s only scoring low here because TVLine readers have bad taste in their comedy viewing choices. They don’t watch Louie. No, they seem to prefer Glee and TBBT. Trust me, she’s going to win. She’s an Oscar winner, she is well respected in the acting community, she always pick great roles, and she actually has a line in the show where she says, “Your sperms are dying in my mouth right now!” That whole conversation on oral sex etiquette and values was the dirtiest, funniest thing I saw on television all last year. Louis C.K. likes to push the boundaries of comedy, and it’s going to pay off for Melissa Leo. Now having said that, let’s all take a minute to mourn the fact that Kristen Wiig didn’t get nominated for playing Young Lucille on Arrested Development. Because she nailed that. It was fantastic.

    • HAP says:

      Melissa Leo’s turn on Louie was both fearless and hysterical. Although I never thought of her as a comedic actress, this was golden.

  21. Steve says:

    I dont understand how GLEE is a comedy and how Dot marie Jones is voted for in a comedy. The episodes shes been in and her role have Been DRAMATIC – not comedic. It just makes no sense. Glee has music but I dont find myself laughing at any episode

  22. Belle says:

    And the Emmy goes to…Elaine Stritch!

  23. jm says:

    it gets on my nerves when people complain that a performance is not comic enough… it is “best performance in a comedy series”. Glee is considered a comedy. How many times a dramatic performance has won an emmy in comedy categories… Laurie Melcalf comes to my mind…
    Dot-Marie Jones was great in the shooting episode… she is doing quite great work, she deserve the emmy… but with an old lady in the run… she has no chances… emmy voters love their oldies…
    And now with people from SLN competing here… it is so wrong…

  24. Jake says:

    Oh Hell no Dot Marie… Glee is the lamest show on TV right now. It does not deserve any nomination whatsoever!