'Law-Enforcement Crushes' Semifinal: NCIS' DiNozzo Vs. Castle's Castle! Vote Now!

Welcome to the first of two Semifinal matchups in our Ultimate Law-Enforcement Crushes Bracket Tournament — where NCIS‘ Tony DiNozzo will do battle with Castle‘s Richard Castle for a coveted spot in our Finals.

Castle Scoop: New, Heart-Breaking Crisis For Beckett

We’re expecting record voter turnout, so don’t delay in racing to the poll below, then alerting your friends and neighbors to do the same!

On Friday, we’ll launch the second semifinal face-off that will test the strength of your respective character crushes, and on Monday, we’ll launch the final showdown. So make sure the right choice is made by heading down to our polls to vote for your favorites (Semifinals voting will be open for 48 hours), and hit the comments to justify your picks.

NCIS Exclusive: [Spoiler] is Back From the ‘Dead’!

Eventually, our battle will boil down to a finale that pits the ultimate old-school crime-fighter against the ultimate modern-day hero. (Their female counterparts will have their turn later this month.)

Oh, and if you’re interested in the match-ups we’ve got planned for the coming weeks, CLICK HERE TO CHECK OUT THE ENTIRE 64-PLAYER BRACKET (then click again for a zoomed-in view), and sign up to follow me on Twitter @MichaelSlezakTV.

Now what are you waiting for? Vote!

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Wennuhpen says:

    TONY! TONY! TONY! This guy just has to smile and I…. *censors self due to adult content*

  2. bpc says:

    Di nozzo all the way

  3. Sheri says:

    Even my husband knows to leave me alone during Castle. And Im so glad ABC put Castle On Demand so I can demand it over and over. Castle is yummy!!!!!!

  4. First of all….they are BOTH HOT!! They have their different ways. YourEyesOnly/Dinozzo makes you want to eat him up on sight, while Capn Mal/Castle is yummy on the eyes, he’s matured enough for a deep relationship right now. Tony will eventually get there. He IS trying. Would have chosen Your Eyes Only over Dinozzo as a long haul relationship. As it stands now, Tony is a playful snack, while Castle is the real prize. Don’t count Castle short on the moves. Im sure there’s PLENTY of tiger in him.

  5. Christie Sweeten says:


  6. anthony says:

    Has to Anthony DiNozzo #1

  7. castle and beckett forever says:





  8. yo_ always castle says:

    castle, castle, castle, castle

    pleases vote castle


  9. Juanita Narvaez says:

    Love, love Tony Dinozo!

  10. Miss K. says:

    I would be Castle’s Muse any day! What do you say, hot stuff? Wanna shadow a high school English teacher? I promise I will look on adoringly as you solve the “Mystery of the No-Name Paper!”

  11. Joni says:

    Always attracted to classic good looks and smarts. Both Tony and Michael Weather have these attributes so for me it’s Tony with no reservations.

  12. janellybean5 says:

    Castle all the way! :-) Nathan Fillion is on my “list”.;-)

  13. Erik says:

    Go Castle!

  14. Barbara says:

    Love everyone on NCIS……would never miss an episode..won’t watch LA NCIS ..terrible

  15. Bob G says:

    I would have no trouble with Tony, IF THEY WOULD ONLY LET HIM GROW UP ! ! ! I have had a lot of men ans women working for me, and in his case he would have sitting out on the curb wondering what happened. Sooooo childish and completely imature.

    • NoChance says:

      It seems that they’ve finally returned to S1-S4 Tony. The 2nd half of Season 8 is when I started to notice it and other than a few minor missteps they’ve dropped the “Idiot, butt of jokes Tony” here in Season 9.

  16. bphopeful1 says:

    Castle can climb my turrets anytime, anywhere!

  17. Lin Wright says:

    No contest here, Dinozzo all the way!

  18. Maryellen says:

    Gibbs!!!!! And then DiNozzo! ;)

  19. castle says:



  20. beckett says:

    castle I love you

  21. Jamie says:

    Micheal( DiNozzo)

  22. kat rowin says:

    ok ladies…here’s the scoop! it’s definetly Tony! Every once in awhile we get to see that small boy charm in his character, that makes him so fun to watch! I love his sarcastic banter!

  23. NoChance says:

    Congratulations Tony. Way to go Tony fans, you sure came through in the last 24 hours.

  24. JJ says:

    Yeah, TONY won.
    I mean Michael Weatherly is just way better than that other guy!

    congratulations to all the Tony fans

  25. memaw says:

    DiNozzo all the way!!!!!!! Though I would rather be voting for Gibbs. Yeeeeeaaaaaaahhhhhh.

  26. Kaylee says:

    … I just can’t believe that Castle lost to DiNozzo.
    Castle has so much more heart and charm. Tony is just… Immature.

    • Deija says:

      Yeah, well, I thought it would be close…
      But for some reason, Castle fans were unable to vote late yesterday evening and into today when the poll closed.

      We (Castle fans) were ahead, and then we couldn’t vote anymore and NCIS got way ahead, we didn’t even have a chance. :/

      • CaskettFan says:

        I don’t know what you’re talking about. I was able to vote for Nathan fine yesterday and today, and so were heaps of others on Tumblr.

        Unfortunately, DiNozzo won fair and square. We still know our man is better though! :)

      • Whatajoke says:

        Don’t like it when it happens to you, DO YOU? This is what happened to the Booth fans when he was against Castle. There is NO WAY IN HELL that Castle would have beaten Booth if the voting was up and up.

  27. Gail says:

    Gibbs is the best, but must vote for DiNozzo in this round.

  28. patty says:

    DiNozzo!!! He is handsome, charming,and has a sweet vulnerable side

  29. CastleBuffySVU says:

    So disappointed in the results of this poll. How can you don’t crush on Castle? Love the show, characters, and actors.

    • MelindaB says:

      Yeah, me too–how anyone could have a crush on Tony over Castle is beyond me. Tony is kind of a jerk from what I remember from when I watched NCIS.

  30. Lisa says:

    YAY!!!! I loove Tony =) …and since Castle beat Booth, I’m even more happy XD …if now Vaughn wins the other semifinale…ohhh that will be hard, I adore both of them. They are the best possible chioces ^^

  31. SpethiE says:

    Tony is eye candie, he’s hot, has that look that makes you melt. He also has the sexiest boss ever. As Gibbs always says “Ya think”. TONY TONY TONY YOU ARE A WINNER XX

  32. Katie says:

    Yeah my Tony won!!!!

  33. Vickie says:

    DiNozzo hands down.

  34. Pam O says:


  35. Castle Should Have Won says:

    Even though I know people were voting for Castle, all day long his percentage never went up at all. I guess lots of women like to be objectified cuz they sure seem to love this dinozza guy

  36. Courtney says:

    Castle fans can talk smack all they want, doesn’t change the fact that DiNozzo is the clear winner! I mean all you have to do is look at the side-by-side pics to see who is more crushable. Fairs and squares.

  37. Overdamoon says:

    Congrats DiNozzo!

  38. Tess Lopido says:

    Watched both NCIS and Castle, voting for Tony Dinozzo of course. He’s very funny and witty at the same time kind and soft hearted and most of all loyal to his team.

  39. Laraconie says:

    Are you kidding DiNozzo he has street smarts and Hey he’s Italian
    Forget about it.

  40. Josie says:

    Since Booth lost to Castle, which i was very sad about, I had to vote for Tony even though I know Castle’s show way better than NCSI, Still he was hotter than Castle, and i could never vote onsomeone who made Booth loose. So Happy for Tony.

  41. Katherine Martenon says:

    Gibb’s is the most sexy man there is as far as i’ m conserned. Beets Tony by a mile. My vote is for Gibbs!!!!@@@

  42. Monica says:

    I found the contest on twitter but I could never vote for Castle, I tried and thought it was my computer, so tried again later and nothing… then just to check try to vote for the rat gay-looking zoolander-wannabe of DiNozzo and boom! The poll took my vote…
    So it seems to me that someone has a lot of issues with the fact that no one likes DiSguzzo and wants to proove wrong with an “Open poll”

    • NoChance says:

      Huh? The poll closed at 5pm on Nov 19 so if you tried to vote after that it was too late.
      And what’s with the defamatory remark that I won’t even lower myself to quote?

  43. Lesly says:

    I love NCIS guys they are gorgeous!! They got my vote! Mr. D 2 tha zo U R Hot!!!!

  44. Brandy says:

    Dinozzo is soooo sexy. He is so much better looking than Castle but hey Gibbs is sexy too. And if I was lesbian I’d have to go far Abby . Ha ha ha

  45. V says:

    Castle is my first of that two but Gibbs is the hotty on NCIS

  46. aris ochoa says:


  47. addie says:


  48. Maureen says:

    I’m so happy that Tony DiNozzo won!

  49. Catie says:

    I don’t even know why Castle was included, honestly. He’s awesome, but he’s not even a cop…