How I Met Your Mother First Look: Katie Holmes as the Infamous Slutty Pumpkin

This Halloween, Ted Mosby will finally meet his Slutty Pumpkin on How I Met Your Mother, and we’ve got your first look at former Dawson’s Creeker Katie Holmes as the legendary character.

Ted and Naomi — I guess we can’t call her the Slutty Pumpkin anymore — will revisit the rooftop Halloween party where they first met in the Oct. 31 installment (CBS, 8/7c). Ted even puts on his old hanging chad costume for the special occasion before introducing her to Barney and Robin, who are wearing some interesting Halloween get-ups of their own. But the episode’s called “Perfect on Paper,” so we’re betting Naomi isn’t the future Mrs. Ted Mosby.

Exclusive: How I Met Your Mother Boss on [Spoiler]’s Return: ‘She’s Part of the Endgame’

The Slutty Pumpkin is just one of many mythologically important characters HIMYM is bringing back in its seventh season. Ted’s Season 1 girlfriend Victoria (Ashley Williams) already made a return, and EP Carter Bays teases that “there may be more [faces from the past] down the road.”