Is The Secret Circle Magically Delicious? Our Fall TV First Impression!

The broadcast networks have more than 30 shows debuting this fall, including Steven Spielberg’s dino-mite Terra Nova, homecomings for Sarah Michelle Gellar and Rachel Bilson, and a U.S. take on the UK’s Prime Suspect. To help you prep, TVLine is offering First Impressions based on the not-for-review pilots. Next up…

THE SHOW | The CW’s The Secret Circle (Thursdays at 9/8c, premiering Sept. 15)

THE COMPETITION | ABC’s Grey’s Anatomy, Fox’s Bones, CBS’ Person of Interest (new), and NBC’s The Office/Whitney (new)

THE CAST | Britt Robertson (Life Unexpected), Thomas Dekker (Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles), Gale Harold (Queer as Folk), Natasha Henstridge (Eli Stone), and others.

More TVLine First Impressions: CBS’ Person of Interest, Fox’s New Girl, ABC’s Once Upon a Time, The CW’s Ringer, CBS’ 2 Broke Girls and NBC’s The Playboy Club

THE SET-UP | Like fellow newcomers Once Upon a Time and Grimm, Secret Circle is about an ordinary person coming to terms with their extraordinary destiny. Here, it’s Cassie Blake (played by Robertson), a freshly orphaned high school student who relocates to her late mother’s hometown of Chance Harbor, Washington. Boarding with her grandma (Heroes‘ Ashley Crow), Cassie immediately strikes a spark with Adam (Dekker), befriends his girlfriend Diana (Days of Our Lives’ Shelley Hennig), elicits antagonism from “Faye, the resident bad girl” (as Phoebe Tonkin‘s character is conveniently introduced), and all told comes to suspect that something is amiss in this waterfront burg. Eventually, Faye blurts it out: “You’re a witch, 100-percent witch,” as is the rest of the half-dozen friends. With Cassie completing the circle, Faye effuses, the teens’ powers can escalate — even though their similarly powered parents abolished witchcraft years ago, following a horrible, tragic incident.

Fall TV Preview: TVLine’s Guide to All That Is New

THE GOOD | The story of an innocent, scarred waif stumbling upon a supernatural situation in which she plays a critical role is not a new one for The CW — look no further than Secret Circle‘s lead-in, The Vampire Diaries. (The kinship is of course no surprise, since the shows share literary lineage, both being born of L.J. Smith’s pen, and an exec producer in Kevin Williamson.) As such, you’re looking at one of the easiest programming calls around, meaning this newbie stands a fighting chance. Robertson is pretty darn perfect as Cassie, displaying sufficient amounts of disbelief about Chance Harbor’s secret circle, until Adam — in a beautifully shot, magical sequence — proves her power. Dekker, showing good chem with Robertson, is certain to cement heartthrob status among the CW fans. As Diana’s dad Charles, who is secretly the big pot-stirrer amongst the empowered adults, Harold oozes malevolence, no more so than in the pilot’s cold open or when he exchanges “words” with Adam’s blabby (yet entertaining) drunk of a dad (Queer as Folk‘s Adam Harrington).

THE… COULD-BE-BETTER | Like I said, Secret Circle is a fastball down the middle for The CW, and not much in this critic-proof series’ pilot screamed problematic. Dekker, while bringing perhaps the most gravitas of any of the Chance Harbor kids, could stand to have a bit more edge. Tonkin walks around with a permasmirk that, while befitting her character, at times reads as over-the-top. Hennig is a dead ringer for The Office‘s Ellie Kemper, which actually is not a bad thing at all — it’s merely distracting in a fun way!

Fall 2011 TV Grid: Where Did Your Favorite Shows Land?

THE TVLINE BOTTOM LINE | If The CW’s Nikita and its action-thriller elements had one problem in this time slot, it was shedding too much of Vampire Diaries‘ audience and demos. If the disconnect between those disparate worlds, and not the competition, was the issue there, Secret Circle should fare better. The big question is if this freshman drama can also draw eyeballs away from ABC’s graying Grey’s and Fox’s late-premiering Bones.

Watch a video preview for The Secret Circle, then vote in our poll below.

Comments are monitored, so don’t go off topic, don’t frakkin’ curse and don’t bore us with how much your coworker’s sister-in-law makes per hour. Talk smart about TV!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Michelle says:

    Matt, you do know that Magically Delicious has been my nickname for Ian Somerhalder for YEARS, right? ;)

    • lorna says:

      HAHA I call him Ian Smolderhalder. I’m stoked, Britt was INCREDIBLE on LUX (RIP) and in Scream 4 and Dekker was cool on HEROES. Will give this a try.

  2. K says:

    I love Gale Harold and I can’t wait to see him play an evil witch. I will totally be watching this show.

    • ash says:

      He’s the only reason I will be watching.

      • Karen says:

        Same here.

        • Sara says:

          yep, same here. I’m enduring bickering and angsting teens for him (something I didn’t have the patience for even when I was a teen myself) so hopefully the EPs will utilize his amazing acting skills well and have him on for more than 2 lines per episodes.

    • jh says:

      Ditto. Gale is God.

      • Mandy says:

        I want to watch this show. I so do. Just for the amazingness that is Gale Harold. That being said, the premise sounds ridiculous and I am not sure I can stand all the teen melodrama and poorly written, over-acted dialogue that plays out on CW shows. I may try the first episode and if I can cringe less than once every 5 minutes, I might give it a try.

        • Lindsey says:

          I think you may be surprised… The books were pretty good. Much better than the Vampire Diaries books. And I love the Vampire Diaries show, so hopefully this one will be even better. I think it will definitely be lesser irritating than the 90210/Gossip Girl type melodramas. Hopefully, anyway!

        • frosty says:

          Kevin Williamson does not write poorly. Please take your negativity elsewhere.

        • Lori says:

          I’m with you. I’ll try to make it through just to see Gale. He is perfect.

    • Loccoo says:

      Warlock, not witch

    • Nicole says:

      When I heard he was playing one of the dads on the show I was bummed because who wants to see Brian Effing Kinney relegated to a nothing role in service of a teen show (ahem, Hellcats)? But knowing that he plays a central, EVIL role is awesome. I’m so in.

  3. Saracen Riggins says:

    I love, love, LOVE the Vampire Diaries. So hopefully this will not disappoint!

  4. AT says:

    I’ll definitely check it out, as these are based on my favorite books as a teenager, but I’m still pretty baffled about some of the changes they made (and I’m someone who is okay with shows/films being different from books as long as they stay true to the spirit of the source material).

  5. GeekGirl13 says:

    I want to check this out but the competition is pretty stiff and I’m not willing to give up my established shows. If I can make the time maybe I’ll watch at the CW’s website.

  6. Elizabeth says:

    Wonder if anyone else noticed that the song Cassie was playing on the radio was in the very first season promos for Gossip Girl. Clearly, I need to watch other channels than CW. Lol.

  7. Captain says:

    I’ve watched Shelly Hennig on Days for years and can safely say she looks almost nothing like Ellie Kemper. If anything, she looks like Nina Dobrev.

  8. PV says:

    Another problem with this series is the extreme white washing of the cast. Would a little diversity kill the CW!

    • sara says:

      They’ve just added Logan Browning as a series regular.

    • frosty says:

      You’re not using that term correctly, and don’t worry if I know Kevin Williamson, half the cast will be gone soon enough! hehe…

      Srsly, KWil is a genius though.

    • Brooke says:

      It’s not whitewashing, it’s a diversity problem. Whitewashing is when you take source material that has non-white people in it and make a new version that replaces those character with white people (for example, The Last Airbender, or the in-the-works Akira movie). The Secret Circle just has a lack of diversity, there weren’t any non-white people in the books.

    • Tessie says:

      OH jeez. Nikita has an Asian [if ugly] lead, VD has had African American characters. THE AA get their own magazine, month, and channel. Quit your whinning.

  9. sarah says:

    ive been waiting for this show since the rumors it might get picked up to make a pilot..

    • frosty says:

      no, the pilot has already been produced, i believe you mean ”ordered to pilot”, then ”ordered to series”.

      • KCatty says:

        I believe you’ve misread. Sarah has been waiting for this show since she first heard rumors that it might be made into a pilot.

  10. CR says:

    Looking forward to this show! The trailer looked great and I’m a fan of the “adults” in the cast, especially Gale Harold. The younger cast all looks pretty good too, some real talent here.

  11. Kevin says:

    I smell a VAMPIRE DIARIES/SECRET CIRCLE crossover event in the works. :)

  12. KBC says:

    I was going to say No, and then I saw the trailer…oops.

  13. Carrie says:

    I don’t really care for “Vampire Diaries”, but I’ll give this show a shot because I know that Britt Robertson and Thomas Dekker are talented actors. The plot seems interesting enough.

  14. Lu says:

    Im looking forward to seeing what changes they make from the book.
    I read them all in the late ’90’s- a bit outdated even then. But, there is so much potential there. They probably changed the number to 6 for practical TV reasons (12 families would be hard to maintain). I hope they don’t change Diana and Faye’s relationship too much- I like the dynamic between the two of loving each other deeply but disliking each others choices.
    I am really approving of the adults in the story- the books were all teen and was missing that layer.
    Also, I hope that they catch what the books missed- about abusing power- whether magical or otherwise. And take more (neo)pagan influences than Charmed did- like how they portrayed magical things or even the magical world- angels, good vs evil etc. But, the effects looks a lot better from what I saw in the clip.
    I hope the spin they do is it’s own smart flavor and not too closely tied the books- so I don’t have to compare them in my mind, after this. But, the books are older(probably not so many die-hard fans) and Vampire Diaries demonstrate that they like to take an idea and go there own direction with it.
    Love that they moved it to Washington. Our state definitely has a witchy or/and earthy vibe.
    Though a roll of the eyes for orphan heroes.

  15. Kevin says:

    Looks like Shelley Hennig’s character is in her Alice Cullen mode and when I saw Natasha Henstridge’s face, that look says it all and we don’t know whether her character is nice or just plain naughty.

  16. wooster182 says:

    You had me a “Gale Harold.” I didn’t need to hear anymore.

  17. Evan Meadow says:

    How long till Britt Robertson’s character sleeps with her teacher with the producers actually trying to justify it and have it effectively kill the show?

    • Jason S. says:

      I thought Life Unexpected did a good job in showing that The relationship stemmed from sexual abuse of Lux and the teacher was ashamed of his part. I don’t remember them justifying it. That being said isn’t the actress in her mid twenties.

      • lorna says:

        Dude Lux and the teachers relationship was beautifully written. It’s a tv show, it’s not like he raped her.

        • Lauren says:

          Yeah the Life Unexpected teacher/student relationship was fantastically written. They actually dealt with the fact that Lux was messed up, that’s why she got with him. At least it’s not like Pretty Little Liars where the writers act like they have some legitimate and epic love story. Vomit.
          Anyway, I saw the second half of the pilot of this at Comic-Con and it was terrible. Everyone in the audience was laughing. I so desperately wanted it to be good, and I’ll still watch, if only for the laughs and Thomas Dekker, but it was not good. The romantic rain-drop scene in particular was a mix of people groaning and laughing. Pretty sure everyone was there to see Nikita afterwards.

          • Lauren says:

            Although a lot of the people on here seem to be watching for Gale Harold, and he was awesome, one of the only good parts of the show.

  18. Amandalynn says:

    Doesn’t this kinda remind you of Charmed? Book of Shadows, instead of the Power of 3 they have the Power of 6? Forbidden loves…just saying

    • Brooke says:

      The books came out before Charmed did, and the books had 12 people in the Circle. And a Book of Shadows is a real-life thing that practicing witches use, it’s not something Hollywood made up.

    • TvCritic says:

      EXACTLYYY!!!! Like Charmed !!!

  19. Chrissie says:

    I loved the books as a teenager many years ago I’m going to give this show a chance

  20. Liz says:

    I have been watching Grey’s Anatomy since the beginning and it has been slowly losing my interest for years, ever since the whole Denny-ghost thing. I think that I might just abandon it for this.

  21. organiblack says:

    On NBC, CBS, or USA this show would be gone in 2 episodes. CW needs shows so expect it to hang around for 20 episodes and then never heard from again.

  22. Jessi says:

    LJ Smith was my favorite author in the 90s, and I was SO EXCITED when her books got republished recently and they did the VD tv show…

    And then all the changes broke my heart a little and I had to stop watching. (No Meredith? No bubbly, Druid-obsessed Bonnie? Saddens me to this day)

    However, as much as I LIKED Secret Circle, I did not LOVE it and re-read it until my copies wore thin as I did with VD. So I will be giving this one a chance, even though there are more changes up the wazoo. As much as I liked the twins, I won’t be heartbroken if they’re not around to be skating through the high school.

  23. Lala says:

    I’m skeptical but I’ll watch it because Gale Harold, an amazingly talented and sexy actor, is in it. :)

  24. Katy says:

    I wasn’t too keen the VD books and LOVED the Secret Circle books, so I’m SO excited for this. That being said, I ADORE the VD TV show and the fact that they pretty much changed EVERYTHING makes it all the more watchable – when I watch films/Tv shows based on books that try to replicate the storylines (Twilight, anyone??) It just doesn’t work for me, as the minor changes and missing plotlines irritate me to a point where I can’t enjoy it! So, for me I love the VD because it’s NOTHING like the books, and I hope the same is true for CS. That being said, I love how Elena is a blonde in the VD books and a brunette in the show and Cassie is a brunette in the CS books and a blonde in the show – strange!! lol. Don’t like that they’ve made her an oprhan though! Not as bothered about the location, at least it’s a decent name – changing Fells Church to Mystic Falls was just stupid!!!!!

  25. Christine S. says:

    I saw the pilot at Comic Con and I thought it was pretty bad. The worst part was it was devoid of any humor, which is not what you’d expect from a Kevin Williamson project.

  26. Phoenix says:

    I want to say that I’ll try it, but the new season of “Bones” sounds a bit more exciting, so this might be an internet catch-up project for me. I loathed “The Vampire Diaries” novels growing up and was stunned that the television TVD is as good as it is — considering that it bears next to no resemblance to the books, I probably shouldn’t be so surprised — so to hear that the same team behind TVD is behind this, I’m a bit more encouraged to give this a shot.

  27. spike says:

    the girls already annoy me in the promo, they come off as really mean and idk something is pulling me off. bad casting